I've been a fan of Sam at 1 but we've got nothing going on in the halves. So much chopping and changing. Tonight we looked like a team with no direction from the halves.

Personally the man we need is Deacon. We look 100 times better when he's on.

Don't we have Roberts for another season after this? Someone needs to make a tough decision as the guy isn't contributing and he must be on a big salary.

Not sure, I think he came on a 3yr deal which means this is his last.

Charnley, he may make some mistakes, but as least he's learning for the future.

When Pat is back I think it won't be a case of Robert or Charnley, but Goulding moving back to the right wing.

Played well tonight considering he didn't get any decent ball all night. Will be interested to see the stats as he did a lot of hard work up the middle making useful yards.

Took his try extremely well too.

<Karl Pryce mode on> If Karl Pryce took that pass he doesn't score < / Karl Pryce mode>

Roberts all day

With game time he will come good.
He will only do so playing at 1 though and on top of that, Sam needs to be back at 6.
Anyway, Roberts for me

Charnley will cone through in time

He signed a 3 yr but arrived a year early which effectively made it 4. Expires 2012.

I'd be very surprised if Roberts manages to get back to the form he showed before his ankle injury. Of all the injuries in RL the Achilles is among the worst to fall victim to. Paul Newlove was never the same player after he damaged his. He lost much of his lateral movement (sidestep, swerve etc.) - which was problematic because almost all of his attacking game was a product of lateral movement.

I hope it works out for Roberts, but I suspect you may have seen the best of him.

I agree, why we persist to play a winger who consistently doesn't perform is beyond me. Furthermore he barely seems interested.

Nowt to do with his ankle or Achilles. Was a knee injury.

Think we should try and get rid personally. He was out of position sooo many times tonight it was unbelievable. Looks like he'll never get his form back.

Realistically how many good games as he had on the wing? Not many at all. all of his best game were as a FB.

Get rid of him, Pryce and Gleeson making room on the cap for a top centre.

But how do we get rid?

Sadly that is the issue. I think Robert should be dropped to the reserves to work on his catching as a FB. Then when he finds his feet possibly move him up to the first team.

rlHuh?rl