But he does now play for Wigan.

I doubt we’ll be debating anytime soon if Kyle Amor is better than Gil Dudson or if LMS is better than George Lawler.

There’s a reason behind that.

Let's be honest......Kyle Amor is miles past his best.

It’s a fair point and another point about how a ‘combined team’ is an impossible task to pick without a huge list of rules you’re basing it on. Are you picking a side for today? For the rest of the season? For the next 5 years? Are you including injured players, suspended players? And on and on. Fear the Vee is bagging Singletons inclusion based on him being a new signing for Wigan, well at least he’s available. Is the combined team for tonight?! If so Walmsley isn’t available. If you’re going on the flip side of looking at a team for a number of years then you’d start picking guys like Lees and Partington in front of Amor because they’re young and developing.

Ultimately a combined team means nowt and we all know Saints are a better ‘team’ than us. Forget individuals and who is man for man in better shape, we need to improve as a team. Saints are lucky they’ve had a World Class coach for two and a half years, who has improved players and but the blocks in place for them still to be a good team. We’re a developing side and I can see a nucleus of players forming who will be able to compete on all fronts but not under this coach.

I understand your point but as NK says, he is now a Wigan player so comes into the reckoning. For my own part, I always liked him at Leeds and thought him better than both Amor (who has never kicked on after a promising start imo) and LMS whilst there.

That's not really my point though. The best prop at either club this year has been Walmsley. After him I would put Bullock comfortably in 2nd. That's just opinion of course. However, the point I was making was that, no matter who you place in a combined team, someone else would be of a different opinion and I used your post to illustrate this as you mention Amor and LMS who wouldn't get anywhere near a combined team in my opinion to replace Singleton who wouldn't get near a combined one in yours.

same could have been said about Amor at Wakey or LMS at London...

You can kinda see the argument against Singleton on this. Yes I've been impressed with him, but you've also got to give some weighting to time served playing in a successful side.

It's the same argument that's been rumbling on for years on why (up until recently) Wigan players attracted more attention from the NRL. Was Sutton a better player than Thompson? Probably not, but he played for a team that was successful and NRL and that counted for him.

You can but then he’s not coming up against much competition, between both sides there is one top class prop and then it’s a group of solid pros, promising youngsters and guys well last their best.

If somebody says pick me a 4 prop rotation for a game next week then it would be totally different to picking one for a side I’d want in place for a couple of seasons to come and beyond.

How did that go for you?

How long do we have to wait for the redvee instant fan reaction video? Usually really honest and neutral in their views those lads.

You'll not see him again for weeks, back under his rock that is Redvee.

Absolutely smashed Saints in that 2nd half, they were never in it.
They had two penalties to get into our twenty which ultimately came to nothing, I said to my lad with twenty to go that these men had gone and we had them. Had Hardaker been more accurate with the boot I think we would have put another couple of tries on them.

But over on social media its all about dirty Wigan and a forward pass.

Beltin'

I don’t want to gloat but I just want Saints fans to admit they’re an Alex Walmsley in front of us. They were Holbrook, Thompson and Walmsley in front but not anymore. Guys like Lees and Amor are average and had they been trying to hold up Wigan’s pack this season like Bullock and Partington have had to do for us, they wouldn’t have even been talked about in a combined team.

Just a bit of respect would be nice. They’re still a better side than us and they’re still favourites to win the comp but when idiots coming on taking about 3 Wiganers getting in a combined team, it’s just silly.

Fair play to them getting over for their try though, you can see why 14 of their players would walk into the Wigan 17.

Exactly.

Always found them to be the same. When they're winning they're the best the world has ever seen. I mean for years they claimed Ade Gardner was a world beater. My Gran would have scored tries outside Lyon and Gidley and she died before they even signed Gidley.