Not if the break contracts to do it. If they go at the end of a contract then that is fair enough but most players are not on five year deals like Joel so if they have say 18 months left on a RL contract they should see it out and then go if they want to.

The obvious answer to the reply from IL is "Well why don't you then?"

We certainly need one.

Your maths is almost as bad as your English.

Just a thought, but might not increasing numbers of youngsters currently playing union come to see a league as a way of showcasing their talents much more effectively than could ever be done in the over-congested mess that's a game of rugby union? It's very doubtful whether Joel would be on the sort of contract he is now, had he come through union ranks. Handling the ball half a dozen times a game tends to limit the ability to catch the eye, I'd have thought.

And were we to draw in more youngsters, sure some might move on but you might turn up another Sam Tomkins or two.