Never rated him myself even when he was a winger with Widnes

Yet he won a Grand Final with Brisbane !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Correct my friend but I still didnt rate him, was he the original 10 minutes impact player at Brisbane

and how many has Rickey Bibey won?

Dont think we even got 10 minutes out of him !!!!!!!!!!

In the current Wigan squad it's Amos Roberts.

Currently Feka

otherwise Paul Koloi, once hailed as "the new Inga"

I remember Jamie Ainscough coming over with a big reputation and he was poor apart from Murrayfield

Martin Offiah.

Dont get me wrong he was one of the most amazing try scorers ever (as we all know). But watching his face squirm up as he bottled another takle just wound me up when he was playing. So you could argue that he was not the "complete" package. I must admit though that his recent "punditry" on boots and all may have tainted my memory of him



the most over rated player of all time for me has to be Chris Joynt, looked like he was asleep half the time.

others

Mark Calderwood - gash player who only turnned up for maybe 3 or 4 games in his whole time here, not to mention being one of the most arrogant "fist magnets" i have ever met.

Danny Maguire
Jason Cayless
Gareth Carvell
Kevin Brown
Erol Crabtree
Keith Mason
Joel Tomkins (second season syndrome)

under rated

Fakir
Bosc (would have him here in a flash, class act)
Elima
Nick de toit (hard as coffin nails)

he was never rated but pure s**te: Niel bains

That there just sums you up. If you have nothing good to contribute could you please vanish. Thank You

Do you mean Neil Baynes ??