Honestly simple stuff this catch. And pass

I don’t see it and to be honest I’ve never seen it with him. He doesn’t dominate in defence he doesn’t really make an effort with the ball and for some the only thing people seem to point to is him banjoing Navarette last year. Every other prop we have offers something tangible. Hill’s last performance was a big step up and he’s been rewarded with sitting in his tracksuit. It’s not how we should be doing things.

Glad its not just me

its completely unusable in Chrome and Edge isnt much better

To be fair it’s a very successful way of doing things. I would be very surprised if he doesn’t make the 17 next week.

I would go as far as to say it would be a disgrace if he does.

[list

Works fine for me in chrome

Me too, as they say.

That’s fair enough but I can’t see Peet leaving him out. He seems reluctant to select Hill if he has more experienced players available. The other two options are Cooper and Walters and they are undercooked.

Credit to wigan for sticking it out there and turning on the style in the 2nd half, Hudds looked dangerous in the 1st half and capable of causing problems.


Liam just doesn't seem to have cemented his place since he came back from suspension, It's been really stop start from him with plenty of errors and not a huge positive impact. He obviously still has credit in the bank with Peet from playing through injuries last season, but he really needs to be more switched on and concentrate when he's on the field. Hill has a good claim to replace him i feel.

Great win, Bevans been good this year but I’ve been waiting for a performance where he reminds everyone why he’s man of steel.

He’s in a lot better shape than he was in feb and with the drier pitches he should start a tear.

Hopefully another big game next week

I’m a Byrne fan but I think we have to leave him out next week because you can’t have so much depth in a position and not use it. We will only drive competition and drag performances out of players by them knowing they’re under pressure for a spot and that they need to perform. I think you can forgive one iffy performance but not one that’s then followed up by a poor performance. Add in the fact he’s not really got going this year and that his tackling technique is currently a risk and it seems an easy decision.

If the disciplinary have any consistency which we all know they don't then Byrne will be sat down next week.
Going off the limited replays I've seen it looked like the exact same tackle technique that got him banned for Lewis last year and Percival this year.

Credit to the lads. That last 40 was probably the best rugby we’ve played so far in the league. We have looked in 2nd gear for awhile but nothings won playing your best in the early/mid stages of the year. Keep telling myself we’re top of the league, only played 3 home games and now looking at full strength, building form

Think Byrne woll play next week I would stick him on the bench for Harvard however it would hinder us as Havard has been great off the bench

Byrne 2 match ban

There are obviously a few options but it feels like Harvie Hill deserves the spot to me. Havard to move up and get the start and Hill to come on to the bench.