If true, I'm sure Widnes would be glad of a winger on loan for the season, then a nie big transfer fee for us from the NRL after that. Plenty time for Manfredi to find his feet before the season really starts properly in summer. Failing that there's Gelling and Thornley as well

I'm hearing he was touting himself out in Oz, another one lost to Nrl

Quote Lippy="Lippy"Some interesting tweets going around; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h U2's Joshua Tree With or Without You - Salford Reds' big Josh Charnley slip-up full details and story of it in tomorrow's M. Evening News lower down in the tweet thread it was followed by; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h It was a costly slip up on Salford's part and then; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h A very interesting story dear - that''s all I can say at this stage - all will be revealed tomorrow So from that it looks like the Doctor may have had him in mind for his marquee signing. Or is it just a good way to sell more papers?'" Looks like it's this story, the ex-scout saying which players he recommended but Salford didn't go in for, Charnley being one. www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... wn-6769043

Quote Lippy="Lippy"Some interesting tweets going around; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h U2's Joshua Tree With or Without You - Salford Reds' big Josh Charnley slip-up full details and story of it in tomorrow's M. Evening News lower down in the tweet thread it was followed by; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h It was a costly slip up on Salford's part and then; Neil Barker ‏@NeilBarker14 · 13h A very interesting story dear - that''s all I can say at this stage - all will be revealed tomorrow So from that it looks like the Doctor may have had him in mind for his marquee signing. Or is it just a good way to sell more papers?'" Looks like it's this story, the ex-scout saying which players he recommended but Salford didn't go in for, Charnley being one. www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... wn-6769043

Edit,
Just a way to sell more papers!

[urlhttp://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/sport/rugby-league/salford-red-devils-turned-down-6769043[/url

South Wales.

This

Or just make him sit out his contract in the stands

Why is anyone surprised by this? the chairman has said he is more than happy to sell players for a fee. He opened the gates where a contract at wigan doesnt really mean anything.

Or option 3. Sit him down, work it all out and get him playing again as soon as possible. He's not the first and he won't be the last star player to fall out with his club only to be back playing for them a week later. Sport is littered with them with Wayne Rooney being the most recent.

The truth is the longer you drag it out the harder a situation becomes, it would be in Wigans interest to sit everyone around a table and sort it out, whatever that may be.
Animosity grows with time.

Agreed. My post was meant as a last resort if he couldnt be convinced to stay. I certainly wouldnt loan him out to a SL club

Well if that is true and the consequence was him being dropped I think going public on it was an even bigger mistake. That just breeds animosity and once that sets in it is very hard to recover the situation.

While the two players may have approached this differently (or in Charnley's case it would seem his agent has set the ball rolling as agents do unfortunately) I don't actually see a great deal of difference in what either of them did.

If Charnley wanted an upgraded contract and was happy to stay with one I would not blame [ihim[/i if his [iagent[/i has handled this badly. If he just wanted to leave that is different and we are back to the same old situation of contracted player wanting away and how the club deals with it.

Had Wane kept his mouth shut this thread probably doesn't exist.

Mistake IMO.