I’m still not sure what Kevin Brown brings to the party. It’s not hard to look decent against a very poor France and I’d like to have seen Williams given a chance in the halves with Gale. He’s had brief stints at 9 and understandably not shone but I feel a bit sorry for him. Hopefully knowing he’s second fiddle to Brown will kick him up the jacksy enough to improve next season.
Not a bad squad though and we should go into the semi final.

Hodgson over Roby is my only concern. He may be a good NRL player but his performances in an England shirt haven't been up to scratch.

Oddly enough the view on Hodgson isn't one shared by most Australian pundits. I think the one thing Hodgson does is attract attention from defenders as they know how dangerous he can be. What England need to do is somehow use that threat to get others into space.

I think Widdopp at full back is a good move as it gives him more space and the chance to choose where he enters plays. When he's first receiver he can be one of those players who looks great but doesn't actually deliver a lot in terms of try scoring passes. Brown did a good job against France IMO of creating a bit of space for Gale. In any event having a third option in attack looke better.

I'm not at all convinced by Bateman at centre, and would have gone with Percival who I thought at least looked like a proper centre against France.

Having said all that, whilst beating PNG isn't a gimme, I wouldn't be surprised if Bennett makes a couple of changes for Tonga assuming we win.

Williams has been awful this World Cup. He's established that he isn't international class, and on a marquee wage.

You think he’s had a reasonable opportunity? I don’t! He’s not a 9, simples!!

He played 15 mins against Lebanon in a spell where we hardly had any ball and about 40 mins against France when he was shifted between stand off, hooker and even centre! He's hardly had enough time to say if he's been good, bad or indifferent (certainly not in his own position).

To put it in to sensible context, he's the only half on tour who hasn't had a start (or even a full half of rugby) in the 6 or 7 shirt.

He hasn't lit things up, granted, and I agree with not picking him for this game, but he hasn't had enough of an opportunity to discount him. What his wage has to do with it is beyond me, England can't buy and sell players.

Williams is still young and learning the game. I think his marquee stays reflects his potential rather than his current level.

As others have said he also hasn’t had a decent opportunity to impress being shunted around positions.

Biggest concern for me is Hodgson back for Roby, and I would rather see Percival in the centre and Bateman instead of Whitehead in the second row. Whitehead has done nothing.

First 25 minutes against France was like watching Cas, fast open rugby with everyone knowing their place. That is gone for this game I am afraid.

It's very tough to deny there's an NRL bias when you see Hodgson selected over Roby and Whitehead in ahead of Currie or Bateman in that backrow. They've both struggled IMO whilst Roby has been superb and Bateman and Currie have outperformed Whitehead.

The team is more then good enough to get the job done on Sunday but I'd have had Roby starting, Currie at centre and Bateman in the backrow with Whitehead and Williams on the bench (with Hodgson in the stands).

I do think Hodgson is a good player, and one thing he does have is a very decent kicking game out of dummy half. But Roby has the faster pass, and has been excellent so far. I agree Whitehead has been disappointing, and Currie has certainly out-performed him, even an out-of-position Bateman has looked better. Widdop at full-back (in the Sam Tomkins role, if you will) looked excellent.

Just on Bateman, despite the jibes of "too small", it seems to me he's done OK so far in terms of post-contact metres, much as he does in SL. He should always be worth a place in the 17 in my book.

I posted about his metres on the VT. So far he's made 152m against Australia, 118m against Lebanon and 150m against France. He's doing what he does best and it's not his fault that the specialist aspects of centre play don't come naturally to him.

In comparison Whitehead made around 58m against Australia and about 80m against Lebanon IIRC. Yes he's defending well but that's not good enough for an NRL star.

I hadn't seen that post, but it tallies with the impression I got.

I do think all this flapping over Hodgson 'starting' over Roby is a bit old skool. It was clear in the first test that there will be a 3 way rotation involving the 2 of them and Lockers. Roby of the three is more dangerous against a team starting to show fatigue around the ruck, there isn't a coach around who simply picks his best 13 with the 4 subs as also rans. We looked a genuine threat against the Aussies in the 2nd half with all of them on, there were pivots all across the line.

As many have said, and has unfortunately been obvious, Bateman is a solid workhorse at centre but is regularly guilty of having blinkers on with the ball in hand. In every game at least once he's had his winger in a better position than himself and failed not just to make the pass, but to even look if his winger is there. He can't be blamed for it, out of position, but it's frustrating when both our wingers are up there with the best in their positions in this tournament.

Kevin Brown - he's an easy target for folk citing Wire's shambles last year, but the team looked the most balanced it has been all tournament with him on the field last weekend. You can't ask for players to be picked on form and ignore that. Williams will get plenty of caps over the next few yrs, I have to admit to a bit of relief that he has not been relied on too heavily this early in his career. I genuinely don't think he's ready to shoulder that burden.

Roby was immense off the bench and once PNG have tired themselves out trying batter the English pack, he can come on and mop up. Hodgson just needs to stop trying to be fancy and stick to the gameplan.

Not Brown's biggest fan, but he seems to give Widdop and Gale a bit of space to do their thing, so I don't have a problem with him starting. His kicking game needs to be on point, though.

Williams is still young. He basically wouldn't be at Wigan if they hadn't made him a marquee player - only time will tell whether it was worth it.

The whole Bateman v Percival thing - I just think that Bennett's a bit wary of the size of some of the opposition. He's had ample opportunity to change it and he hasn't. People will just have to lump it for now.