That's not what he said though.
He said "if we have a player who can bust a take he shouldn't be playing wing full stop".
Is that correct?

I'm sure there are plenty of options available and worth exploring.
Lots have been tried this year.

Budgie can do a job at centre but currently he's a winger and making busts certainly doesn't change that or mean he isn't

Correct
And maybe that is the reason for some of the clubs innovations in taking games "On The Road"?
Arguments sake - Wigan kept Season tickets at last years prices (Which in effect is approximately a 7% increase due to 1 less game - Although we may get an extra game at home if we finish Top 4 which can't be predicted and something certain fans forget to mention when we got the "Extra" game previously in my view for "Free"icon_wink.gif.
We don't go to Oz and the fans moan at a 7% increase in prices!

I keep hearing the argument that IL should put his hands into his pocket more, I reckon he does enough.
I'd guess that over the last 10 years not including the purchase of the club he's probably put a few million quid in, but to me that's not the point.
Further down the line he leaves the club for whatever reason and the club needs to be viable.

What were the sponsorship deals in place at Wigan end of 2007 and how do they compare income wise to what the clubs done since? Have we increased it?
Turnover - What was it in 2007 relatively to 2017
Last thing I would want is IL leaving the club and the finances behind the scenes being a complete mess.

Final thing & something I've mentioned before and Rogues alluded to above.
I wished I'd have grabbed the exact details when I had a look pre-season but I compared my seat as an individual & my Family's seat as a group to the price of a Saints Season ticket.

For a similar seat/seats it was individually around £100 cheaper at Wigan - For a family in the region of just over £200 cheaper
Game day prices are generally cheaper by between £1-£5 a ticket

End of the day the Money has to come from somewhere - Pointing out the problems isn't going to help - Being a Part of the solution and helping wherever possible is.

Or to take it to the extreme Ray Mordt. I don’t think he ever scored a try by running round his opposite winger. Just ran over you!

This is why I hate stats or name dropping. For every player who has has success at changing position you could name a failed attempt, or a player who stayed in his position and really became outstanding. There's a lot of detail in positional play, a centre is a completely different position to a wing or SR.

Look at the names in the list mentioned, world class players who could pretty much play a number of positions with ease, not all players are to the standard of a Hanley or Faz. Hanley was a great 13, but would have also been great pretty much anywhere on the pitch.

Yes, but if we're being pedantic you said he's a winger full stop. If you'd said he's a winger as it stands, or he's a winger at the moment then I'd have totally agreed with you. Your implication was that he's a winger and a winger he shall stay. That's a completely different argument to the one you answered my post with.

No I didn't - I said "He could do a job at centre in an emergency, but he's a winger"
So I did say that he could play centre, I'll also tell you that he used to think he was a Full Back and still thinks he can do a job there (I'm not convinced but who knows with 12 months training to play either FB or Centre).

Someone else said " If we have a player who can bust a tackle he shouldn't be playing on the wing full stop."

That is what I disagreed with.

And to draw a similar parallel to the Budgie to Centre argument - How did switching Richards to Centre go?

Every situation is different

Connolly wasn't great anywhere on the pitch. He was a poor to average full back and didn't play anywhere else but centre. Robinson was a hit and miss half but a world class winger. Again he played nowhere else and, in all honesty, I can't imagine which other position he could have played with any distinction. There are a mix of players listed. Some multi positional, some outstanding in only one position. That's exactly the point. There is no 'one size fits all' when it comes to players. Hence the reason I said 'worth a try' rather than 'he'd definitely make it as a centre'.

The simple fact is he shows many traits of a top class centre: good awareness, great hands and the ability to bust a takle to name but 3. He's already an excellent winger. He wouldn't suddenly lose that ability if he tried his Hans at centre. I'm not sure why you think he would. Can you name me some players for whom that was the case?

As I said. If we're being pedantic (which you were) then you said he's a winger full stop. Well, if we're being very pedantic, you actually missed the full stop but we'll let that one go!

You're subsequent post regarding Richards proves this is actually what you think anyway so I'm not quire sure of your reasons for arguing unless it's just more pedantary.

For the sake of clarity, do you think it possible Budgie would make a good centre or not and, if not, why not?

And would you further explain how this went on to ruin him as a winger?

We'll agree to disagree on Connolly but you do realise you're arguing against yourself if that's what you think, don't you? Why would moving an outstanding fullback to centre make sense if moving a good winger to centre doesn't? You can't argue it both ways.

Robinson did indeed play a number of games at full back in both codes and didn't excel in either. You may as well argue Budgie has played several times at centre..

I don't want this discussion to get muddied though so rather than discuss the merits of individual positional swaps let me ask you this: What do you think we stand to lose from trying Budgie at centre (not thrown in this season btw) given we have an abundance of quality wingers and are struggling at centre?

I didn't say it did - I just said that Richards was brought by Millward and he tried to convert him to centre when he had only played Wing previously.
It didn't work and he moved back to Wing quite successfully (He also played a bit of FB 07ish but it was quite clearly Wing was hi best position).
This is what I believe to be Joe's best position - Nothing more nothing less.