Disagree.
Roby is another Higham (admittedly much better). If you said Michael Monaghan or Cameron Smith I would have agreed with you.

Utter tosh!! Fair enough he had a bit of an off night tonight with the ball in hand but he wasnt the only one in horrid conditions. He's been one of our most consistent performers and gets us round the park effectively. It works better when he is spelled with Tommy but that wasnt an option tonight. Whenever he has an off game we get all this "he's not a hooker" rubbish, despite approaching 100 SL appearances in that position at the age of 23 and getting capped for England earlier this year.

Hock
Cross
Sam

Knifes arent out for McIlorum just because hes had an off night, I've never rated him and I cant see anything in him (other than his defence) as to why people think hes so good? He constantly makes the wrong decision. I've lost count of the amount of times this year that he has tried the Kieron Cunningham barge over try and failed every single time. Its a waste of a tackle.

FWIW im not saying we should get rid of him - I think he would make an excellent back rower & his defence is worth him being on the pitch any time, i just feel so uncomfortable with the fact that hes the one whos supposed to guide everyone round the pitch and make decisions he just isnt capable of.

1. Hanson.
2. Finch.
3. Sam.

Lima
Hock
Cross

For his first game in a while and in a new team I was very impressed with Cross.

Hock
Hansen
Lockers

When you say you have never rated him you make it sound like he was 33 and not 23. Sam takes plenty of wrong options but is given the benefit of the doubt and rightly so. Not sure why MM doesn't get the same leeway. It seems he has to be the finished article and as good as someone like Buderous or Piggy when nearly 10 years younger than some.

I would have thought MM's Grand Final performance would have silenced his critics at least to some degree but apparently not. He's not the worlds greatest hooker but neither is he as poor as you make out and time is on his side.

You're not sure why MM isnt given the same leeway as Sam when it comes to decision making? Probably because Sam makes up with the wrong decisions he makes with absolutely spectacular plays of Rugby League, When has McIlorum ever done anything remotely like Sam has which would make fans give him leeway for always making wrong decisions?

Whats wrong with me saying i never rated him even though he is 23? He made his first team debut in 2007, thats 4 seasons ago, when would you like me to decide whether I think he is good enough to make it at Wigan? When he's 33?



Yeah he's had one good game in the Grand Final good for him, do you think thats good enough? Are any of his other perforances on par with the GF performance?

Let me ask you this - if he was born in Sydney, would you want him at Wigan?

Anyway i've had my say on this, i think he is a very good defender but never a hooker in a million years, I would keep him at Wigan but not as a hooker. We need to sign a hooker for next year.

Thats the last i'll say on this with you because i've noticed you always get into debates with other users and never change your opinion no matter how wrong you are, always seem to get dragged into arguments, which is strange for a mod

And you are 100% right and will change your opinion on this? Give me a break. You have made your mind up.

As to being a mod that is about deleting/locking offensive or libellous stuff on here for me not precluding debate. It doesn't stop me from having strong opinions on anything. And I won't stop you or anyone else having the same. So lets have a proper debate about MM on another thread (which I will let you start) because we have hijacked this one.

Which means I almost forgot, top 3

HH
Sam
Cross

Hock
Hanson
Lima

Hock
Sam
Cross