As he has proved by being distinctly average even in Super League.

I feely admit, if Hoffman turns out to be as poor a signing as Flannery, I'll be very upset.

I don't think anyone can seriously call Hoffman world class, he'll hopefully be a very good player and one of the best in the league, but he hasn't been near the Aus side, or SOO lately. That in itself is probably part of the reason why he's over here at a youngish age regardless of Melbournes situation.

if he had a SOO and Aus regular spot he would not be plying his trade in Super league would he?

Same could be said about every Aussie that has come over here. Not sure what point you are trying to make?

To be fair, I wouldn't say Flannery has been a poor signing for us. He hasn't set the World alight admittedly, but he makes the hard yards for us and his versatility has been an asset at times.

Reminds me a lot like Phil Bailey puts the effort in and rarely has a bad game but players like that don't really get the attention or limelight.

just saying none of the Aussies in SL are world class, doesnt mean they arent top class players and better than anything we have in the UK

Hoffman is quality. Nothing wrong with luxury signings when they are that good.