The smart money is on Charnley mate

Charley kicked a few last year and IMO he was a better goal kicker than Sam.

I'd give it to Charnley. He looked a pretty talented option when I seen him have a go last year.

As for the team i've been on holiday for the past couple of weeks so it's tough to make a call. I can't see Hughes being moved from the centres so I reckon-

Tomkins
Charnley
Goulding
Hughes
Russell
Mellor
Finch
Mossop
McIlorum
Lima
Hansen
Hock
O'Loughlin

subs
Lauaki
Spencer
Tuson
Farrell

Gelling and Logan Tomkins to miss out for me.

Gelling to play. Goulding to move to wing.

Logan or mellor and spenser on bench, lockers at 6, faz to start at LF

Sam
Josh
Gelling
Hughes
Daz
Lockers
Finch
Mossop
Micky mac
Eric
H
Hock
Faz

Lime
Spencer
Tuson
Logan / Mellor

No lime for me please.
Lemon and ice

Don't see the point in shifting guys like Lockers and Goulding around when we have perfectly able lads available to play in their usual positions with Mellor at halfback and Russell on the wing (played quite a bit of wing as well as fullback).

I'm sure Russell was given under 20's player of the year a couple of season's ago while playing mostly on the wing so he should do alright there. I've not really seen how he is in the air though and Widnes might see cross field kicks as a good way to break down the defence.

At the end of the day though these young players need to be given an opportunity and the game against the bottom club is the most sensible time to do it as it stands to reason that it provides the best chance of winning with a weakened team.

Should we actually end up losing then it doesn't really matter. It will just highlight important areas that need to be worked on and it's better to find them out now than later on. This early in the season no loss is a bad loss; it's all a learning curve.

Exactly. If players are to be rested then lets not compound the issue by playing others out of position. Goulding needs to stay in the centre as he tries to make the position his own and form the umpteenth time Lockers is never a 6 so simply replace the rested players like for like. If it doesn't pan out in the halfs the Sam can move up, not Lockers.

we definitely need Logan on the bench just in case MM gets injured.

its ok rotating, i just hope it doesnt come back and bite SW on the ass

Well said. It is up to the newcomers to fit into the team, not established players being juggled around to accomodate them and thus causing many more changes than necessary. If Gelling is to start he should be on the wing, and from what I have seen of him defensively this would be his best position for an introduction to SL anyway.

I was relying on loads of points from Richards for my fantasy team. How dare your coach rest a key player against such a woeful side. Its almost like he wasnt considering people like me when picking his side!

Would love to see this happen on sunday.

ouch............bit your arris