Would you say he is the same player he was when we signed him (In which case you're literally mental) or not as good as when we signed him, but currently finding a bit of form (like I said)?

Of course he's not the same player he was at Bradford, I was never saying that for a second. I was only saying he wasn't 'bobbins' or 'made of biscuit'

He was awesome last night, but so was Coley, really happy with those 2 right now.

.....and makes more tackle busts than Morley, Peacock and Graham? All I'm saying is he's nowhere near the superstar he was, and last year I wouldn't even call him solid, he got dominated way too much for a prop, even Castleford were putting big hits on him.

I just think Coley and Stuart look bigger, Fielden looked more like a 2nd rower for the last 2 years a bit of a gym rat. But he looks like he has got back some of the bulk he had in his bradford days. Coley looks a little bigger too.
The one thing that impressed me though last night was even though the arms where flying and the heavy hit s where going in Coley & Fielden looked for the ball all the time never took a backwards step, and when was the last time someone said that about Fielden??? Confidence is also a great factor for proffessional players and Shaun & Maguire look to be giving them that.

Keep it up!!!!!

Andy Coley is our best prop by a long way, and has been for a good while now.

Coley was the best prop out of the wigan pack for me last night and I agree he is underated. He is prone to the odd error but he gives a 100% week in week out.

Coley generally gets less game time than Stu Fielden, this was true of last year too. So if your going to compare stats you need to look at how much time the individual is on the pitch for, then some stats might not look quite so favourable.

I think a pack takes a few seasons to gel together and what we dont need is a huge turf out of our props at the end of the year. I think Coley should get another season,maybe as a bench player to give us some trusted experience to bring on. This way the younger up and coming props are supported in their developing main stage roles. So for this reason and the fact that he works hard and appears to be well respected, I would keep Coley. Fileden hopefully will also get a new deal on realistic wages. Feka needs to impress a bit more.

Lets give praise where its due, well done Coley, you have proved your critics wrong.

You honestly need to learn interpret the stats. He made more tackle busts than Morley, end of story - but he did make ~ 11% less metres per carry carry than Morley, which is why Morley had more go forwards (which is a better thing overall). Compared to Coley though he made more tackles busts AND more metres per carry, and Coley was not bobbins or made of biscuit, therfore I put forward a proposition that neither was Fielden.

I'm deeply sorry that Fielden doesn't meet your expectations, but no matter how you try and view it, he isn't bobbins or made of biscuit and didn't get dominated all the time, just like Andy Coley didn't.

Saying Stu is a far better player and performed far better than B&B (bobbins and biscuit) does not mean i'm rating his performances as good as Morley, Peacock and Graham.

I really can't see how it's that hard to grasp, unless you really just have a bias against the guy.

That's a very sensible and fair post Clifford (and also why when looking at stats I try to look at them as a collection rather than choosing headline numbers like overall metres made).

Honestly at the moment I would not swap our pack as a complete unit with any other team in super league's pack as a complete unit. I think there's more to come from them as well, and i'd only be looking at making a signing if a truly special player became available (like a Greg Dowling or Ian Roberts)

I mentioned them working as a unit in a thread yesterday actually. Our pack is not about individual brilliance but about sheer hard work as a unit. Long may it continue!

Spot on mate.

I said in the week if we were to win our pack would have to produce another good team preformence and it turned out that way.

We don't have a Morley in our pack but what we do have is 7 or 8 really solid players that will work their nuts off and keep the team moving forward.

the pack had to put in a massive effort to stay in the game, the main reason for that is that we seem to have started the season with higher fitness levels than the other teams, it would be a big ask to maintain that level of effort week in week out as other teams get fitter, the fact is we were on the back foot for most of the game, only a massive effort enabled us to stay in the game. i think we are another good prop short of making us one of the favourites to win superleague.

I've watched the game again and Solomona is definatly being used as the 4th choice prop for Wire.