I don't think too many Saints fans are peturbed by today's result at all. Disappointed of course. Worried by what we saw? No.

It reminds me of a Regal Trophy semi in the early 90's when you just beat us with our team of 'up and coming' kids. The following years were pretty good for us.

My overriding thought is that if it takes an absolute last gasp win to beat the team Saints had out today then Saints future is very bright indeed. I'll take us with a full side later in the season.

Great game.

Form and experience means nothing in the derby, Wigan were under par but still found a way to win, whereas Saints looked closer to their ceiling - I'd take the current Champions over a four time GF losing team at the business end, regardless of who has the full side.

I knew StainsFan would be on here tonight with the but, but, but........ excuses. However 5.11pm! That's pretty impressive.

The irony.

The point is that this wasn't the 4 x losing side. Its a very different one.

We'll see who's right.

I'd be worried that our kids are easily better than yours. Three accademy GF's in a row would suggest that.

Kids like Wheeler are good BUT Tomkins, Faz and Mossop are better.

As in my op..............Onwards and upwards for one side.

Look at the team Wigan won with in 2003 - it's means nothing in these games. What would worry me if I was a Stains fan (thank God I'm not ) is how reliant the team is on the go forward of Graham and Puletua, and Roby working off the back of that. When they were off the pitch the momentum completely changed to Wigan for the 10 minutes either side of HT. I can see big problems as it looks increasingly likely both will be in the NRL next season.

Yeah, because Wigan fans never do that.

Oh ... apart from when they were battling against relegation, when they did it all season.

Never mind. Better luck next time.

Different how? No Cunningham and No Gidley? Big difference otherwise

Saints played well, but the youngsters coming in are the same ones that have been losing GFs to the Wigan academy teams for the last few years. They are used to losing when it matters so will fit right in.

i know its not representative , but 2 i spoke to wouldnt have sam in their team today


oh dear

I think you'll find there is a rule about heading the ball.

That action was made illegal and equivalent to a knock on after Saints used it.

So no problem with that penalty, it's in the book, so try another equaliser.

Actually, the Saints youngsters you saw today by and large were in the academy side who beat Wigan in the Academy grand final a few years back - I think it was 2008? Foster, Magennis, Lomax, Ashurst (who all played tonight) as well as Dixon (played in the GF last season), were all promoted from the Academy to the first team when they were 18. For the two years under Potter they all got a lot of game time because from about the second half of the first season under Potter we began to have really serious injury issues. Wheeler and Eastmond were in the previous cohort and both played in Academy teams that beat the Aussies in their own back yard.

We only pick the best of our u20s lads for first team action. We may not beat you in u20s grand finals, but that doesn't mean we don't have very talented young players in those sides. Most of them, though, will be average and possibly go on to other things. IMO it is far more important to extract the really talented ones and promote them to the first team than to win u20s GFs.

Given that you are the reigning champions and had only two of your players missing, as Wigan fans you must be very worried that you could only beat such a young Saints side by the score of a try obtained from a forward pass that even your coach recognised as such. But us Saints fans are delighted by what we saw. And to think, Makinson is only 19 and that is only the third time he has played in a first grade match, and he has yet to play a full match at this level. In terms of talent and commitment, these are very, very encouraging times for us.