you are all talking utter crap i bet if u asked bbc personally theyd say wire saints final im not being biased just i honestly think that would be perfect final and it dont matter what would be perfect final anyway its gonna be wire saints so deal with it

Huddersfield in the final would be a bloody hard team for anyone to beat.

Rugby League doesn't need a Wigan v Saints final. It needs a final that will showcase the best our sport has to offer in this comp - this will be done by the best getting through the semis.

To be honest, I don't know why I've replied - stupidest topic ever.

i reckon from a geographical and historical view hudds (yorks) v Wigan (ok its in GM, but close enough to Lancs) is the best.

roses final

or would folk prefer a cheshire v merseyside (sefton) final.

i'll go for the roses final......it'll apeal more the the rugby league public in lancs and yorks.

it will be either of 4 teams

Quote: Abe Frohman "Can you both fit in a Shakespeare keep-net or would you recommend something much larger?'" Wigan population - 81,203 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigan Warrington population - 195,200 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrington Wigan is only bigger if you include Leigh and i dont think leythers will be too happy about including them your crappy town (no offense) Wigan population with Leigh - 305,600 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigan_borough So as you can see, as a town, Warrington is over twice the size

Quote: Abe Frohman "Can you both fit in a Shakespeare keep-net or would you recommend something much larger?'" Wigan population - 81,203 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigan Warrington population - 195,200 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrington Wigan is only bigger if you include Leigh and i dont think leythers will be too happy about including them your crappy town (no offense) Wigan population with Leigh - 305,600 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigan_borough So as you can see, as a town, Warrington is over twice the size

Not only a bite but a 15 minute attempt to escape the clutches.

I'll buy a couple of loaves and be able to feed a small village with this catch.

wigan v st helens or
st helens v warrington or
huddersfield v warrington
wigan v huddersfield

i hope this solves the problem

How much you prepared to wager?

Let me know then ring a mate of mine that works at BBC Radio Manchester.

He happens to be a Wigan RL Season ticket holder.

He is happy to represent the BBC for the purpose of the argument.