Dallas was a left winger.

Personally Dallas.

I want my wingers to score a try when they are put through a gap through pace and a step.

Richards is a solid enough winger (and deceptively quick) but not a patch on Dallas imo.

Take the now too common cross field kick out of the equation and his record would be much worse.

Good kicker though.

Those stats for Offiah look a bit dubious - 12 tries in 10 games? Or is that just Wembley appearances?! He scored 10 just in that 1 game against Leeds!

I prefer Dallas, he can create something out of nothing, one day I hope to be speaking so highly of Ainscough, he can create something out of nothing too. Richards is an awesome finisher though.

Tough, tough question!
Brett was Wigan thru and thru.....But then, so is Paaat!
As a pure winger, Dallas would get my vote everytime.
For versatility though....Richards would be the man.
In the perfect squad, Brett on the wing and Pat as FB with kicking duties.
[iSimples!! [/i

I'd have to go with Dallas but only just. I just think he had more of an excitement factor which is what everyone loves to see in a winger!

Brett is an electrician now.........rlhttps://www.rleague.com/db/player/d/dallas_brett/index.phprl

True Legend.

If Dallas was available to us now in his prime someone else would simply have to learn how to take the goal kicks.

Dave

he owns his own lecky business in sydney. He's quite happy doing it as well i'm told, with plenty of free time to spend with his family. He trained as a sparky part time while as a player in Oz and is now carrying it on. Though i'd love to see him back in the game at some point, i don't think it will happen. I'd love him to come over and work with the wingers at wigan, show them a thing or two.

Obviously not the ginger 1

OMG this question really disturbs me.

It's like that scene out of "Sophie's choice" choosing between one child and the other AND I WILL NOT DO IT.

You are such a bad man to make me even think about it

Impossible to choose between them, both are diffrent in there own ways. Brett and Pat were/are great players, only thing I will say both were the best Aussie signings in a long time at Wigan both did/have stayed for a good few years and didn`t just do a few years for the money.

Pat or dallas is a hard one to call dallas was a fans fav as is pat but if i had to choose one pat because at the moment we dont have a kicker with at least 80% ratio which is needed in SL.