In regards to Marsh, I was just basing his performance tonight on his previous first team performances, thought he was much improved.

Yes but like I said before we have a lot of new faces in our camp we need matches and time to gel, we also had 4 major players out for us which would of helped us dramatically, even a full strength Salford side would of had to play well to beat the Champions so without them we did even better.

[uMissing for Wigan[/u



Richards

Roberts

Fielden

Finch

Gleeson

cant believe the arrogance of some pie eaters on here,yes we know your super league champs,you were not good enough last week and only had 5 day turnaround(just like us)we had a captain out,did bomb chances and a better team would have prob beat you tonight,i dont recall many seasons ago when it was the other way round at our place!!you will prob be in final again,but my money is on the wire to topple you,thanks for boosting the gate and learn to get behind your side without a frigging drum!!all the best

5 days is enough isn't it? And come on you only played Salford you should of murdered us? Saints and Crusaders did why did you fail? The Super League trophy will be heading out of the DW in October there are 2 maybe 3 other teams better than Wigan this year. Huddersfield, Warrington, Saints.

The lads a winger without doubt for me. He just never lifts his head whilst in possession and his first up tackling isn't strong enough. I trust Maguire and Wanes judgement fully and they obviously see something in him but he's had a slow start to his first team career and he'll need to improve an awful lot if he's going to hold down that right centre spot.



As for the game tonight it was a case of job done. We weren't great by any stretch but a wins a win and we move on. The fact that we could win a game tonight pretty easily whilst playing nowhere near our best shows the problems we face when it comes to competing with sides like St George. We aren't pushed hard enough week in week out to be forced into getting all the 'little basics' right.

May I ask how are we being arrogant? By stating that we didnt play well, which we didnt. And neither did you. But if as a Salford fan you want to be pleased with that performance then go ahead, it will get you nowhere.

True - but I think that's at least partly because he used to beat people for fun at U20s level, and hasn't adapted to the better defenses in SL. He'll learn, just needs some more 1st team games under his belt (and may get an extended spell now...?)



Most of our players had their faults tonight, don't think it's fair to single out Marsh.



I didn't think Salford were all that bad, actually. Their kicking game was far better than ours, and they showed quite a lot of individual skill, they just don't seem to play as a team. If some of those half breaks they made had been better supported, they could have made things a lot harder for us.

I was very impressed with Sneyd(think that was his name) for Salford.



Is he a young lad? He looked like he could have a big future.

But you have the backup we don't, we had Bailey, Anderson, Holdsworth, Boyle out, and Ratchford went off in the first half, they were covered by Marc Sneyd a 19 year old kid Adam Neal a 20 year old lad and Jack Spencer 20 also none have had a lot of experience in SL where as your back up have all played in big games and won trophies, that’s the difference.



Oh by the way that Tompkins the skinny one really needs to stop lashing out after being tackled otherwise one day someone is going to give him a real good hiding!

So did we not have Marsh + Charnley playing? Must have missed when they both played in big games.

Yes being backed up by current internationals who have bags of experience, it’s like with any good team (saints) (leeds) (wire) you can afford to put kids in and do ok but teams like us who have a thin squad we really struggle with even one of two players out never mind 5.