Saints appealing the appeal again

Hurrell, Walmsley and Makinson are massive metre makers against us in the past. The first 2 are good for an offload too.

Other than Paasi we seem to handle the others okay.

If however is playing hooker holds up okay for us, it should be a Wigan win.

Assistant coach I believe.

Gotta start somewhere.

Quote: Stu M "Fair points however as much as Hurrell is a turnstile in defence, he offers an attacking threat close to the line as evidenced by his try on Good Friday Also yes you are right in that Whitley and Wingfield would not be in a first choice 17 but they would be first choice replacements. So instead of those we are looking at Royle and Davies- a huge drop off There is no doubt Wigan have the stronger squad and I know you are missing a few too, I just feel that our absentees will impact us much more.'" Funny things happen in rugby league, remember this? https://amp.theguardian.com/sport/2003/ ... e.sthelens

Quote: Stu M "Fair points however as much as Hurrell is a turnstile in defence, he offers an attacking threat close to the line as evidenced by his try on Good Friday Also yes you are right in that Whitley and Wingfield would not be in a first choice 17 but they would be first choice replacements. So instead of those we are looking at Royle and Davies- a huge drop off There is no doubt Wigan have the stronger squad and I know you are missing a few too, I just feel that our absentees will impact us much more.'" Funny things happen in rugby league, remember this? https://amp.theguardian.com/sport/2003/ ... e.sthelens

Embarrassing. I'm sure they have form with this.

Failed appeal again, but no extra game

Failed appeal again, but no extra game

Failed appeal again, but no extra game

Best of five

12 players set to leave Saints, any worth keeping? https://www.seriousaboutrl.com/12-playe ... and-94521/

12 players set to leave Saints, any worth keeping? https://www.seriousaboutrl.com/12-playe ... and-94521/

Genuinely not sure what games you have been watching him in or how many but he is the epitome of bog standard. Him and Royle are just not Saints standard.

I think the truth around Davies is somewhere in between the two posts above. He was far more impressive under Woolf than he has been recently, whether that's through tactics or lack of opportunity I'm not sure. I don't see where he ever starts regularly for an ambitious club but a good reserve to have with a bit of utility. I think he could get a bigger contract and a starting gig in lower SL but wouldn't be surprised if he stayed in a similar role he has now.

As for the rest, it's very quiet on the recruitment and retention. With quota spots potentially to play with it will be interesting to see what develops.

I believe Mata'uita is off which would be a real shame, he's been immense. Hurrell I'd replace, there were some rumours about Opacic coming in a couple of weeks ago and that seems to make sense, doesn't quite carry the physical threat but pretty skilful and much better defensively.

I'd lean towards keeping Blake although he's been very hot and cold. I think that's a theme with most Antipodean signings in their first year though, and would expect some improvement. Providing he wants to stay of course.

Burns showed up well on debut and is certainly worth keeping. The rest I can take or leave depending on what cap they take up, who is coming through the academy to the first team.