I think he's definitely one of the best , I'd maybe have him top 5 but definitely more 5th than 1st

Off the top of my head I'd say something like robinson, vainikolo, Richards, hall, makinson.

Charnley is definitely a great try scorer but not really close to these guys all round for me. I think Robinson and vainikolo are probably more spectacular but the other three are just all round great at everything.

The fact there is a thread on a Wigan forum discussing saints players says it all. There is no thread in redvee talking about Wigan players being because, no one cares lmao

There’s a difference between knowledgeable rugby league people who post on this site, of which you are not one, and a bunch of inward looking Saints fans (exceptions being some Saints fans who engage on here). If no one cares then why are you posting? It’s a discussion about the best SL winger, a category which Makinson fits into. People can either agree or disagree with what I have posted on the subject as long as they give their reasons. I suggest you just go and boil your head and let the rest of us get on with what we know best, debating rugby league.

We are on a thread named-WiganvSaints discussing Tommy and various wingers which all seems relevant to this thread.
There maybe no thread about Wigan on redvee but Wigan do get mentioned a lot usually in some derogative manner but not all posters are of that mindset.
On here the likes of Stu,FTV etc do contribute to a discussion on RL matters where as the likes of Rob contributes jacksh*t and continues to do so which begs the question why does he/her,she/him do this they/them could be lonely and in need of a cuddle this could be the reason he lashes out for the attention his parents never gave him.We as fans of the greatest game of all should maybe put our hands of friendship out to the little fella to show we love him and his mates in his head.

Why is this idiot not banned from the forum yet?

Isn't letting me quote the original but my 2 pence on the Makinson debate is that I think there's a real debate between him and Hall, and I wouldn't really have any problems with people putting Hall ahead of him. Great player. I'd have Makinson quite far ahead of Charnley though. There's more to being a winger than just scoring tries. Tommy has been huge for us in many aspects, including defence where he is immense and has also been incredibly important to our style of play with getting us on the front foot when returning the ball. Obviously he's a great finisher as well. His try scoring stats will be negatively impacted by our style of play over a lot of his career, plus years such as 2015-2017 where we just weren't very good.

Thank you for your input Stu. It is a pity that our ‘friend’ couldn’t post a reasoned argument.

Apparently the most incompetent/outright corrupt display of refereeing ever seen has taken place today at Salford

I thought that was last week?

What do we reckon regarding this post?

The Clown
Posts regularly
Today at 16:50
#870
On a separate note I’d love to see someone decapitate Marshall the ing rat.

p.s. it didn’t really say ‘loving’.

Somebody on here said Saints fans didn’t post about Wigan on Redvee

absolutely unhinged.

and they seem convinced there's some plot involving the referees.

Paranoid scouse imbeciles

Try not to sit on the fence.

Interested to read what people’s thoughts are on the yellow card last night? It’s amazing how red cards are given for the likes of Makinson at Cas but only a yellow for an intentional head shot on Delaney.

I thought the ref was hopelessly out of his depth last night. How he missed the Simms shoulder charge is beyond me however that fired us up so it wasn’t all bad.

Welsby is getting back to his best and was class last night. Forwards were great too.

Zig- wondering what you think of Stephens? He’s certainly not looking out of place at this level.

Thought the yellow was the correct call personally. Yes, we've seen reds for much less but I'd say that's more of a problem of those red cards being dog calls rather than last night being a red. The ref was right that he did hit the back first and slide up. The shoulder charge was a shocker though, and should have been a yellow at the very least.

Personally, I can't stand soft red cards. I think the fact that people are calling for at least 1 red a game now has shown how far the sport has fallen. Red cards should be reserved for serious foul play and stuff that stands out, I don't think they're needed anywhere near as often as they're shown. They completely change and more often than not completely ruin a game and seeing as many reds as we've been seeing is just effecting too many results, skewing the league table etc. Look at that sending off we had against Salford. We were absolutely cruising that game, got a soft red and then they came back and won. Completely ruined the game. I'd rather we use the yellow more often as a deterrent rather than risking ruining the integrity of the league by dishing out a load of reds