Any other ref with a pair of balls would have shown him a straight red, but not a "homer" like that French .

Both Tomkins are becoming liabilities, which does not bode well for England

Joels was shocking. Should have gone, and as such should get a ban.

Sam did nothing wrong. Neither Mcguire or Sinfield made any attempt to get their arm out. Sams arm wasn't even clamped down, the ball was the only thing touching the players arms.

Sinfields was a lot worse than Mcguire, he just lay there and didn't make any attempt whatsoever.

Joel deserves a ban.

BUT so does Sinfield for his high shot.

I'd love to kick McGuire too

I hope he gets banned for it TBH, he has given away so many stupid dirty penaltys this year he needs to learn his lesson.

Absolutely. Leave them at home so they're rested and ready for next season. Suits me fine.

that's exactly what I thought I saw at the match too, would want to see it again before making any accusations though...

I agree, it should have been 10 mins and nothing else.

Maybe a warning by the RFl league this week but IMO should't be banned, he didn't kick him hard.

He does some very silly stuff nearly every week, i bet your coach won't be happy with his silly pens he gives away.

I thought he bit Tomkins, it looked like that.

But Tomkins didn't say anything.

What I did see is, if you play that tackle in 'slo mo' that McGuire elbows Tomkins full in the face. And for the rest of the match you can see Tomkins having problems with his jaw.

He shouldn't have kicked out though.

Although he is the most penalised man in the league, its still a pretty strange thing to do. There are some rumours flying around about him being bitten, but I didn't see anything at the time. We'll wait and see.

See nothing has been mentioned about the Leeds spear tackle which went 'on report' again..!

I watched it in the pub on big screen, it looked like danny maguire give him a little elbow in the tackle, can't see how the could have been a bite to be honest.

IMO it was nothing and should be left at that.

It wasn't that bad mate, wigan did one as well. Both was nothing really.

The jaw injury came from when he slipped and knocked on. He fell into Keith Seniors hand, completely accidental. He started feeling his jaw immediately after.

The kicking incident itself probably wasn't as bad as it looked. Deserved a yellow for the action, some ref's may have gave red. Probabaly won't get a ban as he didnt really follow through.

However, Thierry Alibert should be slapped with a wet fish several times. He is consistently an awful referee and needs to grow a pair of stones. The RFL must be able to find a better referee than that idiot in France.

If it would have been a competent ref, it was a yellow card.

And I certainly wouldnt have wanted to be in his shoes when Shaun Wane got hold of him at 14 all!