I thought this was a rugby league forum? It's inevitable that people are going to discuss a players' strengths and weaknesses.

Don’t be Facetious, of course you are allowed to air you views, just don’t get the hump when someone disagrees with you.

He'll learn all the moves, and he'll learn the art of not being predictable. That's what makes him such an exciting player. I hesitate from using the term 'prospect' as he's already proved that.

Sam is still finding his feet in the big time, I personally wouldn`t say he is greedy he likes to run with the ball you cannot knock him for that.

You're right. I think it's great that he goes on his own sometimes.

Considering how good is he is with ball in hand, it hardly matters.

It makes a change for a Wigan half back to run at the line regulary then just catch and pass ...al al T Smith

I despair, I really do. We've got a young lad who is as big a talent as we've had in years with the potential to become a Wigan RL legend in time and we have people picking holes in his game at the age of 20.

Perhaps you think Christ could have fed 6,000 if he'd sliced the bread a bit thinner!

Sorry Paul but you definitely suffers from the very English malady -Tall Poppy Syndrome.

The thing I like about Tomkins is that he mixes it up, sometimes passes, sometimes takes the line on to keep the defence guessing.

I assume he took the OP girlfriend.

I don't know about that, I think Ryan Hall may win it, 22 I think he is, don't know if that's too old mind to get the award.