Voted for Deacon but either Pat or Deacon will do, it's nice to have 2 world class kickers in the team.

To be fair Pat was dire last season. He missed more kicks at goal than anyone else in Super League. His previous performances should see him keep the job though I think. Plus the fact that Pat is a guaranteed starter, whereas Deacon might sit the odd game out

pat after today

It's only one game and we haven't seen Deacon kicking for Wigan but 4 from 4 by Pat today, a couple of difficult ones too, looks like he's nominating himself to be the kicker once again.

Doesn't bother me if Feka kicked goals (if he could actually kick), any of 'em will do!

PAAAAAAAAT all the way i cant see deacon playing every game and we dont need be upstting pats consistancey by letting deacon do the job every so often

1st Pat
2nd Deacs when he is one the pitch
3rd The pig

Stats

2009 Richards 69% v Deacon 79%
2008 Richards 78% v Deacon 83%
2007 Richards 81% v Deacon 83%

Overall since Richards took over kicking duties in '07 - Richards 76% v Deacon 82%

I voted for Deacon to kick when he's on based on the stats, especially as Pat had a bad year with the boot last season.

phelps kicked a few good ones from touch line

Surprised it took so long for Phelps to get a mention (I assume most posters including the original poster didn't go today), Phelps hit a couple of beauties which effectively won us the game. Goal Kicking coach (if we have one) seems to be doing a great job on first show. Personally it's a simple case of being Pat's job to lose.

I'm just glad we have an abundance of goal kickers. Just look at Wakey, bet they wish they had a decent replacement kicker today..!! Similar to last season, Stains were shocking at goal kicks without Long (remember the Slug missing all his kicks, including the very kickable last minute matchwinner)? Let's hope our success at goalkicking will win us a few close games this season.

All I can say to Pat, Deacs, Riddell and Phelps is to continue practicing, I'm sure that ALL will be needed to do the job at some point during the season...!!!!

Thats the goal kicking sorted, all we need to do now is concentrate on is scoring tries and defending..

1st choce would be Richards because he deseves at least a crack to try and keep it after his long term kicking form for us over the past few seasons.

He wasn't at his best last season though and if after 5 or 6 games he's down at around last years percentages I think the job could well be moved onto Deacon who obviously wouldn't let us down.

To have options of Richards, Deacon, Phelps, Riddell and Roberts for the goalkicking is a good position to be in.

phelps kicked 2 stormers again st Wakey so we ve got plenty of back up

A few seasons ago we didn't have a recognised kicker. Not a bad position to be in now

Pat
Deacon
Pig
Phelps
Roberts