didnt seem to have a plan 2nd half.

He scored the winner but up until that point, he hadn't done much and looked jaded to me. He got the winner and full credit to him but it masked what was some tiredness imo.



Carmont, whilst heavily strapped didn't seem to be too affected by the injury, his mistake in defence happens all to often for the leg injury to be blamed.

If you can spot Tomkins looking jaded but not see Carmont struggled last week then i have to wonder exactly what you are looking out for?!

I agree Carmont struggled last week, however tonight imo, he didnt.

If Carmont's leg was a problem, he'd struggle in the pre-match fitness tests. If you fail the tests, you probably won't play but if you struggle in the tests, I suppose you are assessed and Carmont must of passed fit, Webster's try was a copy of the Wakefield, the week before. It happens all to much if you ask me.

We don't know the reasons behind S. Tomkins not playing it could be a number of different ones, but I guess we'll never know the real reason!

Move on to Wire!

It isn't hindsight for some of us. He picked the wrong team and I was saying what team he should have picked earlier today.

Dave

Cannot comment, but i think Tomkins looked far more comfortable last week than Crmont, so to single him out and try to justify his dropping on this to me seems n odd one, not least when we could have rested Carmont who did struggle last week and still put out a very impressive backline including Ainscough or Tomkins.

AGREED

However, some were agreeing Sam needed a rest. So it is hindsight for some.

We cant all be as perfect as you

Im not sure what you think goes on pre match, but its not really tests. He in my opinion clearly was not fit lst week nd played, cannot comment on tonight but it also appears Riddell was not fit and he also played.

I wouldnt say he was unfit. Just not very good.

Easy to make the decisions after a game isn't it???

Maybe S.Tomkins would of played and we'd of lost by only a couple of points or maybe won by many! Him playing wouldn't of stopped the Smith, Carmont and ref errors.

I put one to you, would you rest Hock? Looked knakered tonight, think he's due one

Ok remove the tests and apply ''Pre-Match Fitness Assessment'

A couple of people I work with, fella in the pub. Cant remember if anyone did on here, tbh, changed jobs in the last week, havent been on here as much.

Have missed you and the Noble debate