Does it make them good?

And nobody will die if you sing Rogues' versions but more people might join in!

No. I started going to the rugby in 1985 with my Dad. I now go with my son and my Dad.


But they're batting an eyelid now. If it offends so many people then don't do it. Simple.

typical of those who condone foul and abusive behaviour, he threatened me, but he picked on the wrong guy. The stewards ejected him from the ground once he knew what day it was. and there were a fair few around us who applauded my action in standing up to the yobs

So many? When, for example, we're at Wire away, if less than 75% aren't joining in with W*nky Warrington, I'll consider 'going clean' myself


I Wonder what Wigan fans will be moaning about next week, probably us winning games by too many points

Pie warrior
What you did was much worse than some odd words in a song. Violence is much worse than anything I've heard sung on the terraces

The world has gone crazy when it is acceptable to use foul and abusive language but it is far worse to defend yourself and your wife and daughter from abusive and threatening yobs.

The law allows for people to use reasonable force to defend themselves, their families and their property.

If we had more people like Pie Warrior the world would be a better place.

Are you all happy to see ugly violent scenes at future Saints games because this is where we are heading in my view?

Pie Warrior met a threat with controlled violence.

Too many people feel that their actions can go unchallenged, especially the young, and we were all that once. I too would have applauded his actions in this instance, infact, i may well have given one of the other idiots a slap.

Ureka...... someone who actually sees the point being made.

I defended myself and family from the threatening behaviour of the yobs, this in my view stemmed from the fact that they believed that foul and abusive language was acceptable...It is not..... It seems that from replies those who condone the use of foul language in chants also condone the actions of the yobs in question...

I leave you all to draw your own conclusions on the effect this could have on future games if we continue down this route.

good on you pie warrior, sometimes a bit of a sharp shock does the trick. i'm saints and if they had been saints fans and you had slapped them i would have applauded you to.

You think swearing isn't ok, but murdering is? What ever floats your boat sunshine.

20 pages... I think it's time for an announcement from the club!!

think you will find the club have made their point.. they have signed up to the RFL Respect Policy and a portion of this policy is played as a recorded message before every game at every ground..

In the words of Harry Hill only one way to sort this out...fight!!!

but seriously to sort it at the next match ...why dont those who prefer the original words sing them and all those who agree with Rogues sing his version and the loudest will win out either way it will make a beltin atmosphere!

Have you read the RFL Respect Policy? Because it doesn't accept violence and intimidation in our sport (which is far worse than using offensive language). I'd consider starting to watch football as it is more suitable to your natural instincts.