I think you find i made the exact same point on the other thread, maybe you are confusing me with someone else.

And I didnt say you condoned injury to anyone. I said you havent levelled the same criticism at those proposing Clarke masks as you did at the person who put the picture of Clarkes injury on the other thread highlighted your hypocrisy.

Spot on.

You cant seriously be blaming other teams for you giving away the most penalties in the league. Of course you have done better in the games you have given away fewer penalties, thats the sam for everyone.


So now its the referees and other coaches fault as well? you cant seriously beleive that the responsibility for Wigan giving away the most penalties lies with opposition players, opposition coaches, referees and THEN Wigan.
and everyone else would accurately say the same

your attempts to paint Wigan as the victims of a conspiracy where big bad Leeds are being big and mean to little angel Tomkins + Co are silly. Wigan have their fair share of people ready to mix it. They are the most penalised team in the league and Joel Tomkins is the most penalised player. That is the case not because of a conspiracy but because they also arent afraid to mix it, they also arent afraid to bend te rules. Peacock said it was a cowardly act because it was. I have no doubt that if Riddell or Lueluai knew the full extend of Mcguires injuryt they wouldnt have done what they did.

Smokey, if you don't like the way this board is run, you can always just leave.

A lot of opposition fans are given a great deal of leeway on this board, far more so than is shown on southstander for example.

ha ha, 13 odd pages of this and i've read about a handful of decent posts. shouldn't this thread be renamed the slang off match between rlfans networks???

at the end of the day phil clarke is not a wigan coach, player or anything to do with the club anymore. what he said, whether rightly or wrongly was said and thats that. nothing that he said or what we say as a result will prove whether mcguire did indeed bring the injury on himself or not and of course whether he deserved it.

all i will say is what goes around comes around. it seems to me that leeds will take a good battering on saturday and i would be saying that if i wasn't a wigan fan.

as i mentioned in a previous thread where i was subjected to verbal abuse from a mother at the wigan v leeds play off game, people will somehow someway get what they deserve and hopefully good will come of this.

as a wigan fan, i love nothing more than hating the leeds team. maybe it is because of their recent successes since wigans last decade of demise. maybe it is because i am truly jealous of their "support" as sinfield mentioned in a bbc story earlier tonight, a support which by the way wasn't enough to ensure they were the best supported team this year. i'd happily take a loss against saints or wire before leeds and every injustice that has come of us in that leeds game last week (i know we didn't exactly do ourselves any favours) will be flipped on its head come saturday.

wigan will progress to the final and the rest of the rl world will realise what kind of team leeds really are through and through. wigan have won the league the honest way, leeds have won nothing yet because they have not.

For you education and edification ,I reported the thread to the site admin rather than posting any form of justification on any injury , actions speak louder than the words of any hypocrite.
Put any spin on it you like you should be ashamed of that post and your own response . you have no credibility as far as i'm concerned , you've not even got the backbone to admit it was a poor lack of judgment.

Stop trying to pretend you have a valid opinion.

its a legitimate point. Im not calling for mass sackings. Simply highlighting hypocrisy.

You do realise it wasnt me who posted the picture dont you? I said the same as i did on this thread which I am happy to stand by.

As i say i think you have confused me with someone else

The Sinfield thing is more a bit of naughty journalism than anything.

Would you like me to post the screen capture of what you did post which was justifying the post from the other numpty on this thread .
Try to wriggle out of this anyway you want you didn't post the pic AND I NEVER SAID YOU DID . BUT you tried to justify the posting of it .

Yes, please, by all means. Then maybe you could explain to the class how it differs in principle from what i have put on here where i also justified the posting of it

Post subjecthighlighting the lack of class shown by Clarke and some people with regards to Mcguires injury.

yes, and would you now like to explain how that differs from what i have put on this thread. It does do a good job of highlighting the lack of class shown by Clarke and some people with regards to Mcguires injury and highlights their hypocrisy