None of the Leeds players then? That's a Surprise!

And you have the Nerve to say the previous poster knows Nothing about RL!

MCGuire was anonymous and his kicking game was terrible!
The 3/4qtrs received almost Zero ball from him and he didn't dictate The game like a Half back should it wasn't until Sinfield moved himself closer to the action 2nd half did we slightly improve.

Myler was anonymous 1st half but at least "Slightly" better second although that's not saying much!

FWIW based on Smith's other selections I find it baffling that he hasn't selected Burrows in the squad as maybe as a 3 they play better?

And there's nobody going to convince me that the squad wouldn't be better with Burrows/Gleeson/Pryce & JJB in it!

Fully agree Brett, see my Well done RFL post.

He didn't play too well last night in the first half. He was so upset with himself when he mistimed his run for the try. But I think you have been a bit too harsh there. He improved in the second half and made metres. He's bound to go down eventually. He's not Moi Moi. (although even Moi Moi surrenders to tackles sometimes!) He is a ball carrying prop, there to distribute as well as make metres and some of his passes were excellent.

Take it your joking?

McGuire and Sinfield had stinkers bar a 10minute spell at the start of the 2nd half when Sinfield pulled himself together.

Not saying i disagree with the other names mentioned bar maybe Graham and Shenton who i thought did ok-ish. If Graham could have held onto the ball he'd have been doing alot better.

Graham look more dangerous than any of our forwards lastnight. and he didnt go straight down from every tackle.

Bar one or 2 errors i thought Graham was pretty good last night. A couple of players made him look abit of an idiot(Burgess was one) by dropping perfect passes Graham had thrown to them to put them through gaps.

He should start next week.

Thought it was a night for the old guard really, peacock Morley and ellis stood out for me! if anything it looked like graham was trying too hard which can gave the reverse effect at time. you could see there was a lot of personal frustration in his performance. I said graham needed to have a look at himself, well that's not always a bad thing. a little more composure would see him kick on again imo

Oh dear

Well its been on all day with no responses and it slipped onto page 2



How odd! I'm sure all you knowledgeable (icon_surprised.gifopsicon_smile.gif folk who posted on this thread would have made sure it was 40 pages long by now if Sinfield was the player you made out

He puts in a sensational performance against the World Champions and nobody has anything to say. I suppose your silence says it all!

No, general consensus seemed to be that he was useless at International level, period.

He controlled the game last night, something he's rarely been given the opportunity to do at International level, but thanks to the inexperience and lack of International quality of the two half backs last night, he was given the game to run and he thrived on it

No consensus was he had underachieved thus far.

120 minutes of good performances at International level and Loiners seem to think he is the best player in the world.

He has to back up this game and a half of good performances to be considered anything more than an International let down.

4.517578125:5