I've said it before and I'll say it again. I think Liam Carberry is a better prospect than Logan Tomkins.

i disagree about low kicks.

high long kicks are best imo with the maximum "hang time" allowing us to get in their faces, or even get the ball back. Pats brilliant at this, spiralling it as well.
He would make a great "punter" or Kick off guy in the NFL, where "hang time" is the priority.

hes already spoke about this himself

would love to see him at the Raiders should Lechler leave anytime soon

would be a good option for him when he hangs his boots up, and a massive pay day.....those guys play on into their 40s.

would get plenty of work in Oakland...

Not to be too pedantic, but Logan has only just turned 19, he's got plenty of time to improve and prove himself at Wigan.

Mellor has always looked good when I've seen him play and I can't understand how he's not been given a chance yet.

According to the official website, Tomkins was born on 1st August, 1991 - which makes him 20. Whenever I've seen him for Widnes he's looked very useful - he guides the team around the park pretty well. Obviously he needs to improve, but the ability is there.

As for Mellor, from what I've heard if he hadn't had the injury to his knee-cap he'd be playing for the first team now. He's very highly thought of.

The expectation of some Wigan "fans" is quite ridiculous at times just because his last name is Tomkins people expect him to be a world beater, Its pathetic for those who suggest that Carberry is a better prospect explain why he hasn't been sent out on Dual Reg as the players who go out to other clubs are generally the players most likely to get the next shot in the first team, So it suggests to me that Carberry isn't as highly regarded at this moment as Logan. I'm sure Carberry will likely go on Dual Reg next season unless of course he ends up like Sam Gee who I thought looked a terrific prospect but as much as we have our opinions ultimately its the coaching set up that makes the decisions not the "fans" as much as some like to wish they did.

Yeah the site is wrong

So because Logan is on duel reg you think he is better than Carberry?

I absolutely do think he is better than Carberry because the Coaches obviously rate Logan higher otherwise it would be Carberry on Dual
Reg & Logan would be in the 20's every week I think it's safe to say that the coaches know more than we do.

Yes, but Rogues said Carberry was "a better prospect", not better, and I tend to agree. He was outstanding tonight, admittedly against very poor opposition...I think he reads a game better than Logan does.

The reason Carberry isn't out on dual reg is that he still qualifies and plays at U18's.