Would like to add Brian McTigue, Bill Ashurst and Eric Ashton to that list.

It's very difficult to compare players from such different eras due to us now being full time with much better training and playing methods. For example I've been watching highlights from all the 8 in a row games in the build up to Wembley, and at times the ball goes as far as 10 metres back on a play, today's defences would surely move up as a line and they would lose that territory. That's only from 20 years back as well. However, from the time I've been watching (since '01)

1. Radlinski
2. Dallas
3. Renouf
4. Carmont
5. Richards
6. S.Tomkins
7. Barrett
8. Fielden (2006)
9. Newton
10. A.Farrell
11. Hock
12. Hoffman
13. O'Loughlin

14. Leuluai
15. O'Connor
16. Paleaaesina (2006)
17. J.Tomkins

I'd like to see Craig Smith and David Furner again now I'm older, got a feeling they would probably get in ahead of Feka and J.Tomkins

I also though Connolly was a better fullback that Radlinski. When he went to Leeds late on in his career they played him at FB.

Sam Tomkins
Billy Boston
Eric Ashton
Steve Renouf
Martin Offiah
Shaun Edwards
Andy Gregory
Andy Platt
Colin Clarke
Kelvin Skerrett
Andy Farrell
Dennis Betts
Ellery Hanley

Strange that no-ones mentioned the points machine we're about to lose, Pat Richards.

The guy that spoke about Richards and Botica points machine. It is all about personal preference and the best players in my opinion.

Players I have seen
 

1. Fairbairn
2. Boston
3. Bell
4. Miles
5. Offiah
6. Edwards
7. Gregory
8. Smith
9. Dermott 
10. Platt
11. Ashurst
12. Farrell
13. Hanley
 

The best Wigan team performance I have ever witnessed was the Wembley win against Hull in 1959. Hull had arguably the most formidable pack in the league and were in top form but were hammered 6 tries to 1 by the Wigan side.

I came from Australia to see Hull beaten by Wigan for the second time in 1985 in the best Challenge Cup Final I have seen at Wembley - seen 20, the first in 1950.

Unfortunately will not get to this one but will be watching it live from midnight Sat here in Aus.

Radlinski
Robinson
Connolly
Miles
Offiah
Edwards
Gregory
Platt
McCormack
C Smith
Betts
Farrell
Hanley

Clarke
Skerrett
Newton
Bell

Henry Paul is very unfortunate to miss out but you can't break that Edwards/Gregory partnership and Dean Bell can't not be in your 17. He could cover the back line and also the back row and lets face it was hard as nails.

Not very many people goin for martin dermott at hooker. Just wanderin what peoples thoughts are on Dermott and how he would compare with present day hookers?

Not many people goin for martin dermott at hooker just wandering what peoples thoughts are on dermott and how would he compare with present day hookers?

I think Dermott would cope in todays game. He was an excellent distributer and tackler.

I would have him in my team - only McCormack has been close in ability (with Newton probably third on the list)

From players I have seen.........


1. Tomkins
2. Boston
3. Bell
4. Miles
5. Offiah
6. Kenny
7. Gregory
8. Smith
9. Dermott
10. McTigue
11. Ashurst
12. Farrell
13. Hanley

I'd go with something similar but would have Edwards at 7. and Inga at 3.