Odd response, as far as I can see there have been a few people suggesting that the 4 min thing may not work. I can't see that anything for a 1 min section of any game could ever be co-ordinated, what about:

a) people who don't hear
b) people who don't do
c) people who forget as they are watching a game
d) anything in the game that would distract

I don't think that anyone has said "no" in the thread, and even if they did - it's up to them! Unfortunately the kind of attitude that you are showing is exactly what turns people away from giving/supporting.

You have just done this worthy cause more harm than toungue can tell with your childish attitude . Watch you dont trip over your rattle as you leave .

Plenty of people on Saturday at the Stoop who might not be the type of people who would join in a demonstration of support as suggested were putting in handful of coins / notes into buckets to support this worthy cause .Each to their own way of support . Bye Bye .

What a well thought out, grown up response to some constructive feedback.

Don't talk soft!

No-one on here has said we shouldn't support the cause, and everyone on here has said that they do support it!

I suggest you go back and READ what people have said, including the bit where you will get some idiot saying 'stand up you miserable sod'. Clearly that idiot would be you, wouldn't it?

Wind your neck in, and remember what AJJ is all about. It's about Jack. Not you.

If when we play saints wouldn't it be better to request on the 4th minute the ref stocks the clock and all players and fans do it?? That way everyone will have an idea of whats happening as its shown on the big screen and then the commentry team can't explain whats happening to those watching at home. Just standing up and doing it while play is happening would seem confusing and may not be picked up by sky. We have over a month to sort something and considering the Saints game is for JoiningJack it would better than big one.

Seems a bit odd to do it during the game. If something is happening in play, a fight, try, penalty etc, no one will do it.

If it's being done, do it at the start.

Should be in the 12th minute.London 2012 and all that.

Are you serious?

Unless the teams decide to play golf I can't see how this is possible.

sweet lord.

Please tell me you are not older than like 6 or something?

He will be back later asking if you can pay on the gate and if he looks like Phil Bailey....

Would it not be better to do it pre game and have the players from both teams plus match officials stand as guard of honour doing the salute with the crowd and let the Johnsons walk out on to the pitch with Jack and the ambasadors for the cause. We all do the salute, Eddie explains to the fans watching at home what is going on and the cause, everyone is happy. If this doesn't happen then i am going to spit my dummy out and call you all knobs .

I think i might get shot for saying this on this forum but hey here goes!

Didn't the Latics fans arrange a 1 min applause in their final game in the 8th minute to celebrate 8 years in the premiership? I wonder how they arranged that so that all the fans knew - couldn't we do something similar to promote?

One of them mentioned it to the other before kick off.