To be fair there's a lot of Saints fans that would probably shoot you at the mere suggestion of dropping Gaskell. I don't agree with the Meli thing, yes he has his flaws in defence but last year him and Foster were racking up the points. Gaskell must make way for Wheeler if he stays fit. We can't waste his talent at centre.

Gaskell will be making way for Hohaia once Wellens is fit.

That seems a bit of a waste. Gaskell is better than Wellens.

Saints should bite the bullet and use Wellens as a utility player on his return coving fullback, centre and back row as and when players are injured or need a rest. He's been a sensational player and servant to them but they can't afford to let sentiment get in the way of progressing.

Either that or use him as a traffic cone in the car park!

I'd like to see Wellens used as the back off the bench that Simmons likes to use. He is far past his best now and the only reason he will play this year is through sentiment. I'd prefer Makinson or Lomax at Full Back.

Personally I don't see it as wasted talent at centre. You have to play as many of your best players as possible. Wheeler at centre is only a waste if you think the centre spot does not have any prestige. I think that's a bit short sighted given the quality we have had at centre.

Last year we lacked enough creativity on attacking the line. With Wheeler on one centre Shenton in the other, it gives us good creative players out wide and in the middle.

If we expect to do well just having 2 creative players in the middle and runners everywhere else then I think we will continue to fall at the last hurdle.

I don't see the problem with Meli and Shenton at centre with Wheeler at stand off. Wheeler's waste of talent comes when he can show no more than Either of them at centre but could make a huge difference in the middle.

Wheeler has the potential to be one the best centre's in SL if he stays fit. Very impressed with him against Salford.

I was saying all last year that, talent wise, he's the best centre at Saints (and probably the best 6), just can't get him on the pitch.

No doubt Rogues will hark back to a meaningless reserve game to point out why him and Lomax are rubbish as they lost to Wigan.

I do. Your idea involves Meli. That is automatically a problem.

I dream of the day when I don't see Meli in our line up.

Really ? Good job your dream didn't come true last year him and Foster were our biggest attacking threat.

Saints fans dislike for Meli is like some wiganers dislike for Goulding theyre both threatening solid players theyre good players.


Imagine having Mathers in your team thats something to complain about.

A lot of Saints fans don't like Meli yet as a Wigan fan I always see him as one of their biggest threats. The problem with him though is inconsistency.

He's great one week and terrible the next. There seems to be no inbetween with him.

If Wheeler can stay fit this kid is a class act and will be an international within two years.

I have had arguments with other Saints fan where his best position is and personally I think stand off but others say centre.

I'd say looking purely at his physical shape, that he's a stand-off. Certainly if you look at Wheeler's build in comparison with our own Josh Charnley, then there's a marked difference. Then again physical body shape has not always been a determining factor in deciding what position a players is most suited too. Thinking about it, forget all I've wrote, it's BS.