Maybe it's just me but I am yet to see a decent kicking game from Gaskell?

I have to say: hats off to St Helens, they've done well despite massive disruption with injuries.

Would like to see Cross in there and give Faz a rest, i think he has looked tired this last couple of weeks.

He had one of his best games of the season against Crusaders imo.

He did need that though as he has been a touch up and down.

He and Chris Tuson are very simular in my opinion and both miss tackles. We need a little bulk up front, revert Mossop back into the second row from the bench and Cross alongside him. I cant see any reason to bring Cross back after this injury to have him miss out.

I just can't see them risking both Cross and Mossop in this game. One because it's a big derby game but two because if both pull up that will leave us very short going forward.

Cross to miss out this week and lets see how Mossop gets on. If he gets through the game ok it would then be less of a risk playing both in our next game and if he doesn't at least we'd have Cross to come in.

3 weeks since Wembley mate so Mossop will be fine. Wanna see Cross drop Big Red on his @rse.

He is only meant to have started contact training on Wednesday (Mossop that is) so he's a risk without question.

He's a superb player though and i'd rather have him in the team then Cross so he'd be the first one i'd go with. It's just nice to have Cross back as an option with Hock and Fielden being out of the picture.

I know mate but come on the lad would have been chomping at the bit for the last fortnight, especially this time of the year. These guys put their bodies on the line every week and dont wanna miss out on the play offs.

Of course.

I'm sure Mossop wants to play and he should but Cross may just be a risk too many. He's obviously one tough son of a bi*ch because I can't see how he can be fully healed in 4 weeks. I get the feeling he's going to play through the pain with a protective pad on which is nuts but fair play to the guy.

Fully fit though he still wouldn't make my 17 so I wouldn't pick him when he's got question marks over him. He was brought in as back up and if Mossop is ready thats all he should remain imo.

Anyroad it's up to Maguire and he'll make the right call.

Mossops had a leg injury and may not play on sunday

That would just be you.

We've scored tries from his kicks, he's kicked a couple of 40/20s this season, he's dropped a goal, he gives us distance with penalty kicks and he's kicked some great splitters. He's inconsistent but that's to be expected in a rookie. He scored a try off his own grubber last week.

He's got a super kicking game and I really like him.

In the game we dominated at Widnes I thought he looked a real talent yet got no praise whilst the ineffective Lomax who only came alive when the game was gone in the last 15 minutes took the plaudits.

I'm not saying he's as good as Lomax as an allround player but he looks a more natural halfback to me and looks to take control of a game.

Tell me about it. Explosive running styles are very attractive to watch. But Gaskell is a real prospect his attributes are ignored by most in favour of runners who have an attractive few runs in a game. Lomax is good to don't get me wrong. But Gaskell is no slouch either and brings other dimensions that the likes of Lomax eastmond and pryce dont have.

This is a big big judgement call from Madge. Cross and Mossop have both had injuries that could be so easy to re-occur. Once youve popped your shoulder and can become a regular thing and Cross's arm has barely had time to heal. Just how strong is the bone. If he gets this call wrong and we lose them in the course of the game I dont think we will be able to match them in the forwards particularly with the impact off the bench with the likes of TP. I think the game could really depend on whether madge calls this one right !!!