I agree. Joel was also up against Lomax a lot of the time who is a very poor defender and who himself isnt really a centre which made things fairly easy for him in attack. I think Joel will always run strongly in the centre spot due to his size but he runs it more or less just the same as he would one position in at second row. I am still far from convinced in his decision making and is ability to draw a man and pass to his winger. Also the defence on the right looked very weak with him and Charnley and Saints got on the outside of them far too easily.

due to the half back not covering, thus bringing our defense inside. JT was against Meli wasnt he?

The times when Tomkins broke/made strong runs he was against Lomax.

Thought Carmont was outstanding again today,if he carries on this kind of form for the remainder of the season then you would think that IL would offer him another 12 month deal

He would be an idiot not to, I think Carmont may wish to retire though

George was too good again.. what a signing he has been.

George Carmont must rank as one of the best overseas signings the club has ever made.

What a professional this man is. He is at the wrong end of his career but seems to be in an indian summer at the moment. IL MUST offer him another 12 months. If George does want to retire the club should BEG him not to.

He is not the greatest ever centre to play for the club (though that's not a criticism when you think about the all time greats of RL who have played centre for Wigan, and in the mediocre Soopah Dooper League he is on present form one of the very best centres - in fact I haven't seen a better centre than him this season so far) but his attitude, work ethic and professionalism are second to none. Wigan legends should not simply be those players with superb natural gifts, legends should include players whose efforts in the Cherry and White epitomise the values of our great club. On that assessment George is a true Wigan legend.