Silverwood
Ganson
Erm.............. Maybe he has a point.

Doesn't mean he's any bleeding good though, does it?

He didn't just mean SL, that's the scary thing.

Poor game tonight. 5/10

Result unaffected.

Spot on.

No cause for complaint that we lost due to him, but he's not a good referee.

Monsewer Alibert might be a poor ref but he can shift. He was the only one who came near George Carmonts 80 yard try.

Why wasn't Tomkins.S handed a similar treatment after the first St.George try for use of the knees into the Aussie player while said Aussie was on the floor,and his head butt in the second half,or Mcillorum in the second half for a blatant stamp ito the chest of a prone St.George tackler,a professional foul deserves binning,the above two players were cowardly and deserved a harsher punishment,maybe they'll get it?

Or maybe not because you just exaggerated all those incidents.

That sums it up very succinctly. He is a muppet who can't referee.

I honestly think that he refereed the game o.k. Both sides were up on the "offside line". He let the game flow, what did we want a penaltyathon?

He DID have a word with Sam Tomkins about the tackle on Morris.

The use of the knees happens ALL THE TIME on those tries to the outside. McIlorum was clearly just trying to play the ball - it's not his fault the St George tackler wouldn't get out of the way.

A waste of a referees shirt

I couldn't go to the game last night but I can understand why people who attended thought he did ok. He let the game flow at times. But it was the changing of his mind all the time, he didn't know when it was 4th or 5th on a couple of occasions and he obviously had a word in his ear about a couple of decisions that he didn't see too.

I'm not saying he was biased though because he was rubbish for both sides.

Which is why he should never have been appointed in the first place. Just for the sake of appointing a neutral ref does not mean you should appoint one who loses count of the tackles!