Noble out

Isn't that what we've been telling you DaveO?

Winning the GF will be amazing but I don't believe Noble is the one to take us forward. We need a new coach. Just because we can string a few decent wins together at the back end of the year doesnt make him a good coach, or infact, us a good team. We finished 6th this year - behind wakefield, hull kr & huddersfield. In my opinion we should be finishing higher than those teams with the team we have. People forget the dire rugby we played up until about may? Then we start to put some good results together and people want him to stay on.

My view is, Thanks Brian, but it's time for a change.

The bit in red is seriously crazy though. Surely 'if' we did somehow win the grand final Noble will us taken us to the very top never mind take us forward!

I agree with that. Too many people are swayed by a the last few results and forget the underlying problems. Brian Noble has laid the foundations but we need someone new to finish the job.

I never expressed an opinion, just asked a question or two.

I'm on the fence at the moment, we watch sh|t all season but we do well in the playoffs when it matters.

What exactly would we do if it was the opposite? Hull KR have played some good stuff, but lost both play off games.

We'd be going on about our team bottling it had we done the same.

Like I say they are just questions.

If we won the GF is the job not finished?

Maybe but i too am prepared to have agg on my face if we reach and win the grand final,

Credit to Brian Noble, he has no doubt helped to turn the club around but i just feel that to remain consistent throughout the season we need somebody who is tactically smarter than him.

I agree with the god of biscuits.

No as it would not have solved the serious issue of our lack of consistency throughout the season and specifically our chronic inability to hit the ground running and start the season well.

A GF win would be great but it wouldn't erase that problem and BN has not been able to solve it in his three full seasons.

Grand Final or not, the whole club needs something fresh. Leeds and Stains change their coaches roughly every 3 years regardless of them being successful.

From a player's perspective, like anything in life, when you're used to a predictable routine, to hearing the same speeches every year, a fresh perspective adds a spark.

A new coach would add a spring to their step and make them think about the game in different ways. Little things make big differences.

Just to play devil's advocate, how long was Wayne Bennett in charge at the Broncos? and how many did they win? Still that was Wayne Bennett though

So you would trade a Grand Final win for consistancy throughout the season?