He's certainly good enough to play for the bulls, he'd get in front of Sheriffe and Platt for the wing spots.

tbf thats not really saying much....Platt and Sheriffe are that bad I feel half of the posters on here could get in front of sherrife or platt for the bulls if they applied

I for one hope he progressess a lot quicker than Penny, he seems not to have learned or kicked on (penny), hopefully lets send Shaun out on loan and see if he kicks on because the basic mould is certainly there.

As for Roberts he needs to stay here and train in wet conditions, on a dry track he looks ok, a bit of rain he looks like a 2nd rate pub player.

that cracked me up.....but it is so true. If I was noble id attach a hosepipe to his shirt when he goes out to train at orrell so he can get used to the wet

Exactly. Joel was just as poor as Roberts with ball in hand and as you say his errors were at very crucial times. They gave Saints the reason to hang in the game and hope they could get the winning score which they did.

This Andy Wigan RL guy seems to hate Noble and certain players and constantly just pick up on their mistakes.

Joel seems to have a problem with keeping hold of the ball alot tbh. Hes always one I notice dropping the ball in the tackle alot. Its definatley something he needs to work on

tbh if bailey is back then I would drop joel next week as he did perform poorly. Amos was half decent going forward granted but he was nothing special and as i have said before offers far less in that department than ainny and has as many, if not more, defensive failings. Therefore for me ainny or roberts is a no brainer!!

He's got pace, that's all, he's to small and is a poor defender. He wouldn't get one of the wing spots at Bradford.

If Carlsberg did do posts, They wouldn't use this one!!!!!!!!!

Send Him on Loan!!!!!!!!!!

Well we are all entitled to our opinions, and we'll find out soon enough wether he makes. Personal I think he's to small and in a game that is starting to favour big boys on the wing and rightly so in my books. Granted you are far more qualified to comment on the lad than myself, but from what I've seen of him his positioning when defending doesn't seem good enough also, and as you say he can't deal with the bombs, which in my books makes adds up to a poor defender, I think Shaun Ainscough will probably be left behind. Don't get me wrong, pace is a fantastic asset, but I think being a winger is far more than being blessed with pace these days.

Nobby knows a good winger when he see's one, and I share the same view of him that Ainscough isn't good enough.

I think he will go the same way as Kevin Penny unfortunatley.

Is that bradford's new imported strong running 2nd rower.