Unlike some threads, the comments so far haven't been made just so they can have an opportunity to have a exaggerated whinge about a player performing badly in a poor side, they are pretty much spot on.

He'll get the ball and plod sideways whilst just looking at the defence and waiting to take a tackle. His defence is ok...Until he gives away another penalty. That's about it for Andy Coley.

He's a reserves standard player.

If he ran his weight into the tackle, he'd probably be half decent and make some yards. At the end of the day, he's just a prop, he doesn't have to do the fancy stuff, we just need him to be a battering ram.

Coley might [iplay[/i at prop, but he's never one in a million years. It's not that he doesn't try - he's just under-gunned.

It's like asking a cruiser to be a four-decked capital ship.

Problem is he ain't a second rower either.

He's too slow for the second row
But to "Not-Arsed" to be a Prop

He would be ok if he did a few squats in the off season to bulk up his legs. He is an average player and out of his depth at Wigan, he looked a decent player at Salford and in the first half of last year he did ok but he should have put some size on in the off season if he is to play prop this year.

Hes a penalty machine

Is he really that good?

Seriously though he gives away too many pens he makes lots of tackles but misses alot as well. He just plods along, he i snot the type of player we need at Wigan.

Horrendous player. we need shut of this mon at the end of the season. truely awful

Give over, Fielden was miles ahead of Coley on Friday night and he had a quiet game by his standards.

We should drop him untill then and play O'Carroll and Prescott.