Plenty of these peers who don't respect him still voted for him, though. How does that work?

i reckon the only reason Rangy (i am english) Case has won is because the voters couldnt decide between Sam and Roby, so they voted for Chase

A pap team that doesnt cheat the cap to survive and held you to a draw at their place ? The Goldthorpe medal winner is now the MOS. Sam is a great player and his time will come so , just for once , show a bit of class and congratulate the winner.

Well done Mr Chase

Ive got chocolate medals worth more than the Albert Goldthorpe. Like ive said earlier in the thread RE the MOS its just my opinion. You are obviously gonna disagree because your a Cas fan, thats only natural.

Of course you have, medals i mean, its funny how it was a big thing (the goldthorpe) when it looked like sam was gonna win it.

Sam will be a world beater of that there is no doubt, but while most realise that they still cant give credit to anyone not wearing red and white, and for that reason , you have my pity.
As for wigan haters, the game isnt big enough for hate so please drop the pretence that your lot are special , A damn good rugby league club , but not the messiahs ffs.

Its a game , Rangi was voted as MOS in that game ........ get over it

Its an award that never fails to create confusion.

What is always more controversial than who the award actually goes to is the process itself for me.

Are players really the best judge of who has had the most significant impact on the competition? Do the players have time to watch every round of Superleague and analyse opposition players week in week out?

As i understand it players tend to focus on who their opposition is for the next game (some don't even do that!) and many won't even bother to watch highlights from other games played on the same day or weekend.

Im not sure what the solution is to giving the award more credibility but perhaps some kind of recognised points system would be an improvement similar to the AG medal winner.

Well done to Chase, Roby and Tomkins who have all haD sensational seasons for their clubs - im just not convinced that the players are best placed to decide who wins the MOS.

You're too funny. Mcguire not dirty? haha.

Also you do realise it's voted for by the players, including the final three; so at the very worst he got the third most votes in the league; not bad for a guy who isn't respected by his fellow pros. In fact didn't wellens, publicly say he voted for him too.

That is RLFans made up fact of the day. 100% unadulterated nonsense. Well played sir. I didn't even read the rest of your post, I know from that first sentence that it will be complete dross, embarassing and cringeworthy.

What a joker.

As I said? Said when?

We'll just crack on winning trophies shall we, you have NOTHING to look forward to at all apart from mid table mediocrity.

Let's be honest the average player in SL is of less than average intelligence, who watch far less SL than the average poster on this forum. I was amazed when I heard both Crabtree and Leeds coach McDermott saying that they didn't understand the play off system, probably few of them do.

You wasnt wrong.