OK I can't count but I still think some of the comments in this thread are OTT and premature.

EDIT: Which is two games v Hudds, one v Widnes (scored 3) and one v Crudsaders (scored 4).

So seven out of he eight tries have been against poor opposition but as I sad you can't slag him off for scoring them but equally a little perspective is needed. Likewise the one conceded includes playing against two poor sides. If he carries on against teams like Leeds, Saints and Wire then OK he really will have turned a corner.

Dave

I agree.

I'm one who has "championed" his cause for a while, because I've seen enough of him at all levels to know what a talent he is.
He's doing o.k. and looks as though he is starting to enjoy his rugby again. None of know how bad that injury affected him, particularly confidence wise.

Let's give him a few more games, give him some encouragement and then we'll all probably be in a better position to make a true judgement.

But I will say this again, IMO there are very few British players who have the physical attributes and skill set that Karl Pryce has.

I agree and I think he will get his chances even when Roberts returns.

Dave

So you actually agree with what i said earlier then?

In recent weeks Pryce has moved above Goulding in the pecking order and is now in pole position to keep his place once Roberts returns.

I can't see how that is getting carried away btw or why we shouldn't praise his excellent strike rate over the past 4 games?

I agree that Pryce has just about pushed in front of Goulding, not so much for the tries scored but for the ones conceded. For some reason Goulding seems to have lost faith in his centre defensively and is being drawn in.
That may be a bit harsh on Goulding in that defence is a team thing, tackling is an individual thing and sometimes the problem can be who is defending next man inside the centre.

I can however see the "back three" being Roberts, Pryce and Richards. Look at Maguires Melbourne team with the likes of Slater, King, Folau and Inglis.

My big concern about playing Pryce against Leeds would be Sinfield targeting Pryce with kicks behind him, a tactic they used so often against Lesley Vainikolo.

No I don't agree because he's only played four games one of which was v Widnes the other v Crusaders so it's too early to tell which was my point. More games will be required against better opposition to see if these four games are any sort of true indicator of how good he is. Goulding has played in games against all the top sides and done well in most of them so I think it's premature to say he has moved passed Goulding in the pecking order based on four games especially given the opposition.



Seven tries came from 3 v Widnes and 4 v Crusaders with only one coming against good SL standard opposition puts a different perspective on the raw statistics IMO . But as I said you can't slag a winger off for scoring walk-in tries against poor opposition. It's his job but given the opposition I don't think the strike rate is any great indicator of his potential.

Dave

Does anyone think his long term future is still at centre? The run of games on the wing giving him the match fitness and practice he needs in preperation for moving inside? He's a handful on the wing but as a centre he'd create so much space outside of him imo.

I very much agree with that, and I'll be as delighted as anyone if/when he begins to use them.

You are contradicting yourself here Daave.

In your previous post you said Pryce will still get his chance when Roberts returns. So in order for this to happen he’s gotta have jumped in front of Goulding right?

You might not agree with it but even by your own admission he’s now the front runner to keep his space one Roberts returns and Richards swaps back to the wing or how else would he keep getting his chance?

I expect Pryce has moved ahead of Goulding in the pecking order if only slightly. Pryce is in good try scoring form regardless of how or where he's scored the tries. He's also done well in defence so deserves his place.

In defence of Goulding though, after watching the highlights I don't think he was at fault for the first Crusaders try, although I thought he was at the time. It was a 3 on 2 overlap, Gleeson's man became the second rower, so Goulding's man became the centre Hanbury, who Goulding had covered, unfortunately Crusaders had the numbers and the winger was free. Had Goulding left Hanbury free and stayed on his opposite winger it would have been a much simpler try for Hanbury and he'd have been miles out of position. So perhaps criticism of Goulding is a little harsh. Our sliding defence was the problem in my opinion.
Gleeson got embarassed by Chan for one of the later tries and it's often a 50/50 decision to move inside or stay out wide.

However, Pryce is more likely to get picked out of the two in my opinion. It will be interesting to see how he goes against Leeds, as they are one team that can really test a player with their kicking game.

I didn't say or mean to imply that. He will be in the running for a place and will get in the 19 with a genuine possibility of getting in the side. That is IMO a different position to where he was previously. If anyone is injured or isn't doing the job MM expects than I'd expect Pryce to be given his chance again - not consigned to the reserves in favour of other players. That said it is still to early to say based on those four games that he's higher up the pecking order than Goulding for the reasons I mentioned in my previous post IMO. I don't see the contradiction.

What may mean he misses out on 1st 17 selection is it may be just a straight swap with Richards once Roberts comes back with Roberts at full back. We will have to see but though he has not done his chances any harm of getting more games I think its a bit premature to say he has gone from zero to hero in the space of four games (OK I exaggerate but you get the point).

Dave

Goulding and Pryce have both scored well when theyve played and most tries have been pretty similar from both of them. The one thing that will help Pryce keep his place is his defence. When Amos is back he will go to full back and Richards and Pryce on the wings imo and that trio will be very very solid defensively and dangerous attacking also. If Goulding plays the opposition will target his side whereas they arent going to target Pryce unless theyre stupid.

I dont really know what pryce has to do, he has gotten himself fit, is scoring tries and being all round pretty solid in defence. At the start of the season, we all said clean slate for everyone, and his performances must be a step in the right direction considering what we saw from him last year.

I think he has done pretty well so far this season all things considered.

When Amos is back, im sure he will start from the bench, and if he has his early season form that is a frightening prospect, I wouldnt like him coming on fresh after about 25mins if i was a defender!

Like Madge has said its KP's place to loose.

Played well and must be doing what Madge wants of him as he been starting past 3 games, and rightly so now he is finding his way to the tryline, well done Karl

He's Big,
He's Quick,
His brother is a p****,
KARL PRYCE, KARL PRYCE