To expect champagne rugby with a team missing it's best players is asking too much. The team have exceeded what a lot of fans thought they could achieve. We have lost games we should have won and the won games we had no right to. The team has fought to get to the play offs. And if you look objectively at the performances has produced it's best rugby when needed in the must win games.

I would sooner be going to the GF having played our best rugby of the season at the right time of the season, than being happy making the top eight.

Good question (honest). I guess we'll have to get back to you in two years' time.

I never expected champagne rugby, I expected us to look like we had a clue how to move the ball around and open up a defence, something we were a long way from for a lot of this season. As I say, I'm hoping lessons have been learned.

Very true , and when have our best run of games happened ? At the business end of the season

Every silver lining has a cloud? You should try supporting one of the many other clubs who haven't had silverware for an age or would dream of getting to the end of the season in second place.

So by your logic, we should forget or even ignore how poor we have been because we've got to a final and just applaud everything, challenge nothing and look to maintain status quo? Sorry, I can't do that, it's great that we've got to the GF, it's also shocking how poor we have been at times. I'm sure Wane understands how bad we have been at times, I'm sure IL understands it and I'm sure both will look to improve.

Yes we can all cheer and celebrate getting to the final, we can also highlight our major weakness, work on it and come back a better team next year.

Why this is a crime I've no idea, I'd consider sticking my head in the sand and not mention our obvious weaknesses as far more of a crime.

You could also stick your head in the sand and ignore the injuries,The come from behind wins, it's a team that has come through a season with more positives than negatives. Can they improve? Yes they can the last month has seen that. Better Wigan teams have been nowhere near the GF so credit where it's due to the players and coaching team.

You could also stick your head in the sand and ignore the injuries,The come from behind wins, it's a team that has come through a season with more positives than negatives. Can they improve? Yes they can the last month has seen that. Better Wigan teams have been nowhere near the GF so credit where it's due to the players and coaching team.

I haven't though, I've commended our defense, I've commended our heart and spirit and never say die attitude. I just dont put our poor attacking form down to injuries, because it's been poor for much longer than this season. I find my view very balanced, I comment on the good and the bad, what's more middle ground than that?

I think that pretty much sums it up quite accurately from my point of view.
It will be interesting to see what other new signings will be announced over the next few weeks because although we have shown depth in the squad we are still palpably short of an experienced centre, goal kicker, winger and a 13 if SOL retires.

enjoyed the last month but glad I dont have a season ticket anymore

I'm not saying that the way the attack has functioned is just down to injuries, some of the play has been like junior level. My view is that the team have worked to a limited game plan and I think that has a lot to do with the players missing. They have made their way to the final games of the season with a shot of winning something. When it has mattered against Wire, Hull x 2 the players have produced the attacking skills to get the wins.