Terrible joint for injuries, i'll need a need joint in the next ten years

I'd done my AC ligaments, still suffer from it now occasionally, was agony for months. He has good physios available who'll help him though.

He'll be fine. 3 weeks maximum

seen him in pub today with his girlfriend is looks ok just a black eye moving his arm ok

If he is injured, and misses games, it might be interesting to hear from people who were disappointed that the shoulder charge was made illegal.

Just playing devils advocate.. :~)

Shoulder charges are fine, as long as they are legal. This was a late hit.

It was late, but he was not hit with a rolled up newspaper...

Didn't say he was. As long as a shoulder charge is legal, it can be a thing of beauty. If it's late or an attack to the head then it can also be very dangerous. Much like most aspects of our sport.

We had a similar conversation at the Huddersfield versus Warrington match on Sunday.

There's a definite difference between using the shoulder forcefully and effectively in defence and a shoulder charge that's reckless and dangerous.

I sort of understand why the "shoulder charger" has been banned, but I've seen a few penalties since the implementation that were, for want of a better phrase, a bit soft. Even Brett Hodgson got penalised for one yesterday and it was the best tackle I've seen him make since he started playing over here!

Tommy L had it mastered and it was a wonderful sight. However a few too many people arent skillful enough to do it and try and be a big man only for it to be a direct head shot.

The shot from Griffin was certainly late, but the actual shoulder hit wasn't something that would have warranted being penalised last season I don't think. Wasn't high, at the head or specifically aimed, just solid and Matty Smith came off unlucky from it

Maybe not as bad as first thought - he's not completely ruled out for Sunday, though Wane says it's "unlikely".

[urlhttp://www.wigantoday.net/sport/wigan-warriors/smith-is-a-big-doubt-for-challenge-cup-trip-1-5658886[/url