This evening.

Obviously the Irony of your post and the image on your Avatar is lost on you.

Personally i hope neither of them gets a ban. I quite fancy seeing

Sam Tomkins
O'Loughlin, Mossop, McIlorum, Coley
Hoffman, Lima and Joel

Up against

Mason, Griffin, fa alogo, O'Donnell, crabtree.

Especially after last season. It could be spicier than a vindaloo. Definitely one to see live rather than watch on Sky

If only Hock was back already!

Unless I'm watching the wrong incident, Sam doesn't look to throw a punch. He runs in and starts grappling with Radford.

That's good enough for me!

From the timings on the discipline report Sam is being done for the 1st punch up when Yeaman threw a few and Joel responded. But Yeaman is up for striking after Joel clocks him with his elbow in the second incident!!
Not quite sure how the RFL have come up with Yeaman and Joel not being pulled up for the 1st fight! But then again they have missed the on report incident completly to!
Radford runs in and isnt up for it but is up for dangerous contact on Tommy!!
Doesnt say much for the rest of the Wigan and Hull players if they managed to join a fight and not throw a punch but Sam does!!

Thanks for that. Couldn't make it to the game so was unaware that Sam was involved in the first bust up.

I think Yeaman is charged with the incident in the first punch up, if he isn't then it's a complete joke. He didn't do much wrong in the second incident, everyone came and in not many punches were actually thrown. The first punch up was instigated by him and started a brawl so he must be up for that, otherwise the RFL have made a right cock up.

Sam must be up for punches thrown in the first punch-up. In the second one, I dont think anyone actually threw a punch. Havn't seen the first one since I saw it live and even then I missed how it started so I couldn't tell you if Sam or anyone else is likely to get a ban or not. It wouldn't surprise me if Sam got a game or two though.

What's the RFL's previous on these type of incidents?
Hopefully they both play in our game, i personally prefer the opposition at full strength.

no one notice radford run 20 meters and start uppercutting if sam tomkins gets banned so should radford

Well the Joel incident is the same charge that Carvell was faced with after leading with the forearm in a game against Castleford (I think it was last year) before facing Wigan. He was given a 1 match ban then had it overturned. With that in mind, the RFL should show consistency and Joel shouldn't be banned, as they should come to the right decision the first time round.

Sam should be banned for 1 or 2 games if he's run in and thrown punches. If he hasn't thrown punches (as someone on hear stated) he'll be let off, but if he has then it has to be a ban for him.

Sam doesn't throw any punches in the brawl AFTER Joel runs into Yeaman. I've yet to see footage of the fight that kicked it all off though. I'd be very surprised if Sam was the only one throwing punches in that incident though.

It was against Cas, I was there that night bloody freezing with rain. But Gareth's offence was not as bad as the photo that I have seen of Joels.