Charnley could be as good as Hall one day but he's certainly not yet. He had a poor game last night and isn't having a great year to date IMO.

I think he's suffering from the chopping at changing in the back line tbh.

It's swings and roundabouts in one-off games. Wasn't it the league match at the DW early last season where Charnley danced round Hall for a hat-trick (should have been four but for a harsh obstruction call)? Hall is the better all round player at this time, especially in the air (on attack and in defence).

True enough and probably a sign of Charnleys great form last year compared to this that he could totally destroy such a fantastic player as Hall in that game.

He'll find that form again i'm sure as Goulding settles back in to his role at right centre. I think Boston, Offiah, Robinson etc would have struggled to make much of anj impression with Jack Hughes as their centre tbh! I know he was inside Thornley last night but he again proved he's about as much of a centre as Sam Tomkins is a prop forward.

I would be absolutely gutted as a Leeds fan.

Gutted, really? Have a word.

If we lost Hall, arguably the best winger on the planet at this moment and replaced him with Charnley who is still potentially very good but not quite?

Yes, I would be gutted.

That wasn't the original statement though. Who said anything about a direct swap? He said if we signed Hall (ie added him to our squad which includes Charnley) OR Leeds signed Charnley and added him to their squad (which includes Hall) then neither would complain.

If that was the original statement, then it really didn't merit a post. Talk about stating the obvious.

I don't think Charnley's better than Hall but he's obviously very good. There are 3 better wingers in Super League tops

Without sounding biased here, I have said for the past 2 to 3 seasons that the best two wingers in world rugby and in either code too are Brett Morris and Ryan Hall, I still haven't seen anyone better this season either

I like Josh as a winger too though and I do believe that he has so much more potential and improvement in his game which is still to come, so you've got a cracker there too

Hall is a better over all player, but Charnley can (usually) find the try line and is a better finisher.

Love to have Hall at Wigan.

Not having that.

IMO (atm) Hall is better than Charnley at all facets of the game. Except maybe speed off the mark. (And goal kicking probably)