He wasnt pulled out, simply didnt make the grade over Charnley.

Reet. Cert to be in now then.

I'd go for:

Roberts
Goulding, O'Loughlin, Carmont, Charnley
Tomkins, Leuluai
Prescott, McIlorum, Coley
Hoffman, Farrell,
Hansen

Decaon, Lima, Mossop, Tuson

Sort the discipline and we should win. Lots of stupid errors today, which all need to be addressed this week by Madge.

I don't know why people harp on about or perceived poor discipline? The style of RL we play means refs are always going to give penalties against us.

Do people really think we could, or even should, go all the game without committing some sort of offence?

Discipline wasnt the problem, that was the problem for them. Our problem was intensity, it was shocking until after the red. We looked miles better when we stepped it up after we went down to 12.

Not convinced Maguire will play anyone else at fullback if Tomkins is available.

I can see where you are coming from, but Lockers is just too much of an attacking threat in the middle of the park at loose (just look at charnleys trys, they wouldnt have been scored if Lockers was outwide at centre) I do think we need someone bigger out there to help Goulding, sure any of our 2nd rowers wouldnt let us down if we were desperate.

Well if Deacon isn't fit, who other than Sam is capable of playing 6? It only leaves Lockers.

We look far more threatening with:

1. Amos
6. Tomkins
7. Leuluai

As opposed to.

1. Sam
6. Lockers
7. Leuluai

Possibly so but I bet you Maguire will go with the second option.

I also see where you're coming from but there's no point scoring tries if we're conceding at an equal or faster rate.

So do I. And I bet he's goes with Marsh at centre to. Even if Joel is available to play.