Not too sure he deserves to stay in the team, depends on injuries I guess. What were people's views on Marsh (there's probably a thread on him but I can't see it) I thought he did pretty well, could do with putting a bit of muscle on though as he was hanging off players sometimes when tackling, he seemed to grow in confidence as the match went on.

Start one then before i do

I thought Marsh looked very good and will certainly be one for the future.

At which point did I say he was a great RL player?

He must have some compromising photos of Michael Maguire.

Ainscough at Widnes and he gets a game?

PS. Ainscough is still joint top scorer at Cas.

You didnt but i would have hoped that he could have made his mark now.

I thought he was solid if unspectacular today.

He got put into space once and scored from it. He also looked enthusiastic to take the ball up when we were under our sticks and made decent yards in the process to.

Obviously he made the TWO mistakes off their kicks but he also did some good things in that dept as well.

The people who think he was rubbish need to get a grip. He was far from rubbish or unenthusiastic like someone else pointed out as well.

He defiantly however did enough to keep his place against Widnes and I hope he can build on today and get better each week.

How people can defend him is beyond me, he doesn't look bothered at all.

he didnt look happy when he scored a try, does this guy ever crack a smile?

I doubt he could crack an egg.

Give him a fúcking break some comments on here are embarrassing. Your acting like he's made massive errors that have lost us the game. He didnt have a bad game. He had a better game than Ainscough did last week but of course Ainscough is from Wigan and Pryce is not so therefore Ainscough is better than Pryce.

I'm basing my argument on the fact that he is playing for the first time under a new coach, so I'm giving him a clean slate, the same as every other player. Then I'm looking at his performance today, he made one knock on, and nearly made one mistake from a kick early on. Other than that he did nothing wrong.

Your basing your criticism on how he looks, by that logic, Ryan Atkins is the worst signing ever, I mean, look at his hair!

*Edit*

Just read the Marsh thread. You posted;



So, you loved how Marsh bombed a certain try (at a crutial point in the game) by not simply drawing his man and giving it, instead he got white line fever and went himeself, getting pushed easily into touch yet you hated Pryce because he knocked on.

Marsh made a couple of errors in defense, Pryce made none, Marsh you loved, Pryce you hated.

Marsh had a good debut, but it'd be nice if you compared players by the same standards.

What does it matter what he looks like?

I'd rather look at the things he did today.

He was always there to take first drives up on our line (something he’s never done before), he defended well, ran the ball hard and took his chance to score when it was given to him.

He certainly wasn’t my MOM nor was he rubbish either.

His so called ‘mistakes’ weren’t that bad either;

The first fumble he managed to regain the ball and not get shoved back behind his line even tho he’d lost all momentum there. Actually thinking about it, it was quite a good recovery there by him

His 2nd dodgy moment for his knock on could have been given the other way for interference imo. Again the fact he made the mistake was down to him wanting to get us a quick PTB which is strange for someone who isn’t bothered about the team isn’t it? Also this mistake came off the back of a strong run which is again something he doesn’t do.

His third moment was his only real mistake of the game for me. He defiantly made a hash when he went down for the ball but luckily nothing came of it and certainly not a massive mistake.

So what exactly did he do wrong apart from failing to smile at the camera?