What about Coley's stupid kicking the ball away penalty?

btw, I can't wait for Rogues to see this thread.

Coley isn’t an angel but looking at the Leeds game for me he was hard done by. Kicking the ball away in disgust at himself shouldn't have been an penalty imo and his 'late hit' was again a very harsh call as there was minimal impact at best. A penalty for both of those is laughable when you think Senior got the same for kicking someone in the head? Kicking the ball away or kicking someones head which one is worse?

For me he's been excellent for the past season and a half now and i'd love to see him give us one more year at the top.

Even if we bring in a top line prop and Coley starts from the bench we'll be in a much stronger position having him here.

his penalty doesnt wipe out the excellant season he is having. Coley IMO has been up there with the best this season yet he is the unpopular prop and never seems to get much praise. Infact I cant believe some people wanted rid of him after the Leeds game

Feka although recently improved has been poor for the last 18 months yet in the popularity stakes he is still crowd favourite. Coley and Fielden go about their business week in and week out yet get called rotten on this board at times.

Sign both Fielden and Coley - even if Coley plays a bench role next year that would make us very very solid

It's all relative to who else we can bring in anyway. If we can get a quality prop from the NRL and another prop from SL/wherever, there's no point resigning them both.

Both Fielden & Coley have played well all season and should be in line for new contracts. Feka seems on the outer and not getting much game time.
Prescott I think is taking, or has taken, his finals this year for his law degree. That has to be a distraction. He's young, big and mobile and puts a lot of work in. I do think it would be unwise not to see how he goes in the future and give him another deal.
O'Carroll is not OOC this year so he stays.

The two rumours around seem to be that Sika Manu may come over from Melbourne or Louis McCarthy Scarsbrook may leave the smoke for us. Both are young and have plenty rugby in front of them. Also Hock may return next year.

I don't think we will be short of quality forwards for the foreseeable future. One maybe two additions and that will be it.

Every team needs a big ugly prop and Coley is ours. I would have no qualms about offering him a further deal for next year, and the same goes for Fielden who has a big work rate.

Louis McCarthy Scarsbrook would be a good replacement for either (although a little too penalty-friendly for my liking) but I would have thought that Harlequins would be keen to keep him, being as he is one of their own. I'd be surprised if he wanted to leave but I guess now's the time if he wants to make a big name for himself.

When does Davies fit into all this? Surely he's in line for first team rugby next season?

Don't forget Lee Mossop. Better than O'Barrell and Prescott IMO.

Coley has had nothing but praise on here this season and rightfully so. Feka is a crowd favourite because of his destructive style of play more tha anything.

If ever Fielden was going to produce a big performance it was Leeds last week, but he turned in his usual adequate performance. That is as good as it gets now from Stuart; if he stays it will obviously be on much less money, which will free some dosh for someone who can actually take a big match by the scruff of the neck.

I agree with this. I think new deals should take into account how well they perform in the big games like Wire & Saints and in the play offs. I see no reason to not offer them both new deals. Andy Coley has been superb, but probably only has one more season in him, so a one year deal for him. Stuart Fielden's work rate is very high and he rarely misses a match. He's been around the block and, if I'm honest, I wouldn't like to see him at another club. He's not the blockbusting, world-class Stuart Fielden we thought we had initially signed, but he's a damn good prop forward still. I think his contract should reflect that and I would offer him a two-year deal. Feka would be the only prop forward I would replace. I think we need another senior prop forward and I'm told we're after/close to getting Luke Bailey. I would extend Prescott's deal for another year and make a decision out of two him and O'carroll who is going to be the one to keep. I honestly don't think we'll keep both. Ben Davies should get a couple more games this season - similar to the number Liam Farrell is getting - and that shapes up nicely for 2012.

I think our pack is shaping up nicely for next season. Plenty of size, power and skill. Andy Coley, Stuart Fielden, Luke Bailey, Paul Prescott, Eamon O'carroll and Ben Davies. Then in the back row we have some real size, Joel Tomkins, Harrison Hansen, Lee Mossop, Gareth Hock, Liam Farrell and Chris Tuson. Then the best 13 in the league with Sean O'loughlin.

The way I look at it is that we are currently top of the league and guys like Coley and Fielden have been at the centre of all the good things which have got us there. Both for me are better than 90% of the props out there and as long as any potential contracts are favourable to Wigan then I wouldn’t hesitate to sign them up. There are very few players out there who will be an improvement on what we have now and although we should be able to get hold of one top prop to complement Coley and Fielden trying to replace both of these and still find another one will be all but impossible imo.

Adding another top prop alongside these two would strengthen us no end. With Feka potentially leaving and Fielden being on reduced terms we’ve got the funds to do this and I’d hate to miss out on anyone.

Factor in the development we should see in Mossop, Joel, Davis and Faz and add a world class talent like Hock into the mix and we should have the best pack in the league next season IMO.