Can we not just sticky this thread? That way the same people can moan about the same thing in the same thread. It would make it easier

roberts is gonna be a quality wigan player, he will be a firm fans fav, you dont buy a player who scored 70 odd tries in 140 games for sydney, he just hasnt had that bit of luck yet to get him goin

A winger who never gets the ball in open space, and it's all his fault

Forget the fact the team couldn't create space in a convent with a box of porn, it's all his fault.

Feckin clueless some people..

At this rate we may have just kept Calderwood.

As for Riddell, well he hasn't done anything yet. And he doesn't look like changing anything.

No wonder you got well beaten then????

I remember Pat's 1st season when he looked like a real bad signing. Not one of us would swap him now!

Amos has got speed to burn and when he gel's with Gleeson he'll cause a lot of trouble for a lot of gteams. He's also good under a high ball and doesn't miss tackles.

I say give the lad a chance and he will blossom

As for Riddell, I've seen very little to make me want him to be keot. The way mike mac is playing it wouldn't bother me if Riddell went today!

He can't do anything unless somebody gives him the ball.

Again, as against Hull KR, he seemed to be left with 2 or 3 players to mark out wide several times as our defence just doesn't slide near our own line. On all but 1 occasion he saved us with a great read.

the reason why id keep riddell in the squad is that his distribution is alot better than mcillorums or leuluais. thats what you want out of a hooker good distribution.

He also made most metres out of any of the four hookers on the pitch on Friday.

Roberts is settling in quite nicely now imo.

He's been solid as a rock these past few weeks and has come up with some huge try saving plays. One at Edinburgh on Pulutua, one at Wakey in in the cup, the Dobson effort last week and numerous crunching hits coming in of the wing at Warrington on Friday.

If only we got the lad some ball

As for Riddell................................must do better but not a total right off just yet.

I like roberts, good player, feel safe with him on our side unlike when we had calderwood, i have no idea how he is a rugby player, he's absolute w@nk

I totally agree, I also think that Riddell is an improvement on Higham, although I wish he would look interested.

Both of them look as though they have plenty of improvement in them though - if they improve as much as Pat did from his first season's efforts I'll be very happy next season.

However, why do we seem, of late, to bring over players who need so much time to adjust. Barrett being a recent exception. I understand all the arguments about moving from the other side of the world, missing family etc. but wouldn't it be good to find more players who have slotted in quickly like Brett Kenny, John Ferguson, the Iro's, Brett Dallas, Gene Miles, Adrian Lam?

You're joking, surely?

He was a good rather than very good import, but my point was that I don't think he took ages to settle in and play to his potential, limited though it may have been at that stage in his career.