No case to answer, x2.

There is, that's why they've been cited and will appear before the disciplinary panel.

Well i guess we will see if the much talked about bias towards Wigan has any truth. Whingeing Wires have a ready made excuse.....

Imo they do have a case to answer. I think carvel went in with a raised elbow .
and morley certainly went in late and very high. we will see what the rfl have to say. I personaly think they wont have the balls to ban both of them.
What will be will be and we will play whats in front of us.

I reckon Morley will miss out, it looked pretty bad and his disciplinary record is hardly squeeky clean.

I hope they both get banned.

I've tidied this thread up with many posts moved to the petty arguments thread I set up. Keep on Topic here ta.

Two matches and one match respectively

If there not banned wire win by 10 if they are banned wire win by 2

Considering our poor record at Halliwell Jones Stadium you should be expecting better than that surely?

Carvell has been charges with a grade c offence which carries a 2 - 3 match ban.

Morley has been charged with a grade B offence which carries a 1 - 2 game ban.

Thats where i got 2 matches and 1 match respectively from. If either of them get away without a ban i would think they have been very lucky.

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

I'll be amazed if the RFL have the backbone to do anything about it, they both deserve to be banned but really cannot see it happening.

Carvell's was a bad one imho. I think the fact that he looked at the man coming in and raised the arm, give a suggestion of intent, whether this was a deliberate elbow is another matter, but there was an intent to raise the arm and this went into a dangerous position.

Morley's was a bad one too, there was more than enough time to relax the arm imho and I think it was a definite case of making your presence felt, but badly timed (and aimed - if had been with the shoulder it may not have seemed so bad)

That said, I'd rather them both play, should be interesting.