1. Sam Tomkins 8/10 Thought he did nothing wrong, kicked well and created a few breaks
2. Darrell Goulding 6/10 Didnt get much ball really
3. Martin Gleeson 7/10 Came in field looking for work, glad he's back
4. George Carmont 8/10 Every year i think 'This must be it for him' but he never fails to impress, one of our best today
5. Josh Charnley 7/10 pass to Hoffman for his try was superb, unlucky not to score himself also. massive fan of this guy.
6. Paul Deacon - cant rate went off to early. thank god he kicked that off the sideline though!
7. Thomas Leuluai 6/10 needs to improve on his long kicking game, it costs us.
8. Jeff Lima - 5/10 was looking forward to seeing him after his rep from the friendlys but didnt do much for me today
9. Micky McIlorum 8/10 please please please stay fit this season, he's really impressing me.
10. Andy Coley 7/10 usual solid self, would miss him if he wasnt there
11. Ryan Hoffman 9/10 my MOM, great debut! Cant fault him really.
12. Joel Tomkins 4/10 had a bad game but we know what he can do.
13. Sean O'Loughlin 6/10 tackled well but didnt really do much in attack

14. Harrison Hansen 6/10 good try & got through a lot of work as usual.
15. Paul Prescott 3/10 Needed to step up today with Fielden out but didnt, his ill discipline cost us, hes a liability at the moment.
16. Liam Farrell 8/10 want him to start next week, this guy is gonna be huge
17. Lee Mossop 7/10 thought he played well, ran the ball in hard looking forward to seeing how he goes this season.

I think Charnley was better than some of the players who you gave higher ratings.

Thought Locky ran the show in attack.

Really? Didnt notice him.

Bit hard to judge really when he didnt get that much ball.

If you can credit Charnley for Hoffmans try and not notice Locky's 2 involvements in the build up I would question your marks for every player.

Sam Tomkins - 7/10 - Tried hard and kicked well but couldn't have much of an impact without the ball from the playmakers.
Darrell Goulding - 6/10 - Fairly quiet. An error close to the line but didn't see much of the ball. Some hard work at dummy half.
Martin Gleeson - 7/10 - Faded towards the end and lacked sharpness but was eager and effective going forward.
George Carmont - 7/10 - A solid performance.
Josh Charnley - 7/10 - Looked comfortable at Super League level and has much more to give.
Paul Deacon - N/A
Thomas Leuluai - 3/10 - Barely noticeable, terrible kicking game although stayed solid in defence.
Jeff Lima - 5/10 - Solid and hard-working but nothing spectacular.
Mike McIlorum - 7/10 - Put in so much effort and had to last the full game. Faded towards the end but that's understandable.
Andy Coley - 7/10 - A typical Coley performance and seemed to do well in defence.
Ryan Hoffman - 8/10 - Very good Super League debut. Dangerous with his offloads, good strength and solid defence.
Joel Tomkins - 3/10 - Anonymous until the ref started to call his name.
Sean O'Loughlin - 7/10 - Constant tackling. Excellent play in build up to the try. Maximum effort but less effective when not playing loose forward.

Harrison Hansen - 6/10 - Took his try well and worked hard at times but also became less noticeable.
Paul Prescott - 4/10 - Defended well but didn't offer anything of note in attack and penalties cost us.
Liam Farrell - 8/10 - Working hard yet again, tackled well and threatened on occasions in attack.
Lee Mossop - 6/10 - Put in some strong runs and some good tackles but very little impact off the bench.

thought charnley looked way out his depth should send him back to hull kr for the next 3/4 years to learn the ropes

I'd be more happy with that game as a Wigan fan than if i was a Saints fan.

Richards, Roberts, Finch and Fielden were all missing and all would walk into the saints side.

We dominated them and lets face it a bit of luck and the ref granted them a point.

whoooosh

Yes Fielden would walk into the saints team...

that's me being p!ssed at half 4 on the internet

oh dear

He would. Much better player than LMS. LMS is overated but he will go well at saints because of the 3 props around him.