..If they was all out of contract at the end of the season, who would you actaully want to retain?

Roberts
Goulding
Carmont
Richards
Leuluai
Paleaaesina
Bailey
O'Loughlin
J. Tomkins
Harrison Hansen
McIlorum
Prescott
Pryce
Phelps
Gleeson
O'Carroll
Mossop
Tomkins
Flanagan
Farrell
Ainscough

So you are happy with the drivel we have to put up with every other week then?

Roberts
Carmont
Pat
Tommy
Feka
Lockers
Joel
Hansen
McIlorum
Prescott
Pryce
Phelps
Gleeson
O'Carroll
Mossop
Sam
Farrell
Ainscough
Davies
Thornley

Phelps or Roberts but not both
Gleeson
Carmont
Richards
Pryce
Goulding
Ainscough
S Tomkins
Leuluai
Prescott
O'Carroll
Paleaaesina
McIlorum
J Tomkins
Hansen or Bailey
O'Loughlin
Mossop
Flanagan
Farrell

All the youngsters yet to break the first team.

J. Tomkins
S. Tomkins
Ainscough
Carmont (for one year)
O' Loughlin
O' Carroll
Prescott
Richards
Leuleuai
McIlorum
Pryce
Goulding
Gleeson (until Pryce is ready unless Pryce is ditched)
Hansen (maybe)

I think It'll be easier if I name the players I wouldn't keep:

Coley
Hansen
Fielden
Bailey
Smith

Riddell?

Obviously adequate replacements would have to be found, regarding Riddell I'm unsure, he's shown signs so would perhaps give him benefit of doubt, as for the others above they can all go for me and thankfully some are.

I would get rid of

Riddell
Smith
Coley
Fielden
Bailey
Roberts

That would open up so much cap space we could do loads with it.

They were the ones i missed off my 'to keep' list bar Roberts who i said it'd be a toss up between him and Phelps so i agree totally.

Riddell is improving but we've got 2 long term better bets in McIlorum and Leuluai.

Coley and Bailey are both steady eddies but there must be better players out there somewhere for the money we pay them.

Fielden is a given to go considering the wages he's on. I'd keep him at the club after his contract if he were willing to accept his worth which is about 60-80k a year and i doubt he'd take that.

Just get rid of the coach and see what a new coach can do with them. A new coach has done wonders for Mathers.

would persevere with riddell and see how he goes next year before we all jump to conclusions! after all, look how crap richards was in his first season in england and yet he is one of the first names on the team-sheet now such has been his improvement!
some players naturally take longer to settle in than others and i think riddell needs a bit longer, he is a long way from being what we all expected but seems to be enthusiastic and is gradually improving!

Of those who have played in the main squad........

S Tomkins
O'Loughlin
Richards
J Tomkins
Leuleuai
Mossop
Ainscough
Gleeson
McIllurum
Carmont
Phelps
Hansen

In that order.....Rest could go for me with possibly the exception of Paleasina, and Prescott

Phelps is on a lower wage and has been better this season IMO.

I'm seeing some good signs from Roberts at the moment.

He looks to be more settled and is having a good imput into most games. His form this year as a whole has been far better then Richards was in his first season and as much as everybody wouldn't have a Richards style rise in form i'm sure Roberts will prove a long term good bet.

We've not got the option of releasing Roberts whereas we have with Phelps but i'd only do that with a cast iron guarantee his replacment would be better and i find that doubtful.