Thierry Alibert has done it again he has let a team score off the 7th tackle and only gets banned for one game.

Next time he refs us the crowd should shout out the tackle count when the opposition has the ball. That'll ensure minimum mistakes. Especially if we shout "5th and last" on the fourth!

Not the wisest choice of game for him to be given seeing as he has made the same basic error twice in a few weeks. That game could easily come down to one score and if he repeats the error it could unjustly end one club's cup run. Just as he wrongly allowed the winning score the first time he made the error. He should have been given a game (as Cummings seems determined to still let him officiate) that is likely not to be close where any errors won't have such a bearing.

Once is bad enough but twice says he's got a serious problem and shouldn't be reffing at this level. The next game he refs for us I think we'll all be counting out loud!

Maybe the PA announcer could play Mambo No 5 when we are on the five tackle anybody can think of song titles with 5 in the song ?

He doesn't referee games, he just wears the outfit and gets told what to do in his ear from the stand. Thats always my thoughts when I see him and I see him as no more then a token gesture to have in the league because we have a French team and also because we'd like a neutral ref for test matches.

I blame his puppet master in the stand.

They can't drop him to the championship, no more refs , shocking state of affairs.

Well the RFL have just admitted Ben Thaler sent the wrong man off in the Bradford Leeds match. The standard of reffereeing is definitely getting better under cummings!

Yep, both HKR and Salford fans are slagging off his replacement (Tim Roby).