He has been superb on this weeks programe. Sign him up perminantly, he made the programme really interesting and gave a real insight into what the players are thinking.

He also gave Wigan some good praise which is rare from the rest who only look at our PTB.

Him and Phil Clarke will hopefully be around for a while on sky, the coverage will then improve when Eddie and stevo leave.

Yep - another plug for Paaaaaaaat as MoS, too!

Yeah i thought he was pretty good too. TBH I don't particularly mind any of the analysts on Sky. It's Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dumber that get on my wick

Wouldn't mind a chat show on sky hosted by Carney with Clarke, Wells, Cullen and Stevo (for comedy) sat around a table discussing the results and ins and outs with people ringing in.

Everytime I watch it makes me think that I would love a Rugby League version of football's "Time of our Lives".

How good would it be to listen to "Gregory, Edwards and Westy" talk about their days at Wigan for an hour whilst being interviewed by Stevo / Eddie.

I really do think that SKY could grab 3 players from each of the following teams, grab some footage :

Hull (Early 80's)
Hull KR (Early 80's)
Leigh (Early 80's)
Widnes (Late 80's)
Wigan (Early 90's)
Stains (Late 90's)
Bradford (Late 90's)
Leeds (Mid 00's)

Would make a great series, and something refreshingly new!

Just watching it now, that's exactly what we said, a breath of fresh air,

Here's the 3 players from that era, ready for interviewhttps://www.scarebearsrealm.com/3WiseSkeletons.jpg" >

I had a similar thought last night, do we have the personalities to replicate "The Footy Show" over here. Im sure we do, Boots n All is fine but it doesnt touch The Footy Show in terms of entertainment, particularly as you Offiah's round up on Sunday aswell as Boots n All The Tries programme to have seen most of the tries.

Wells was very good and although many dont like him I think that Cullen gives a good analysis of games too. Carney, Wells and Cullen should definately get an increasing amount of airtime with Hemmings phased out and Stevo given a lesser role (as already seems to be happening to some extent).

Every time I watch a game with the Australian commentators (like SOO yesterday) I despair at how bad the British lot are in comparison.